Name: advanced self-healing asphalt reinforced by graphene structures: an atomistic insight
Uploaded: 2022-05-31T13:00:00
Description: Watch this Scientific Journal Video about Advanced Self-Healing Asphalt Reinforced by Graphene Structures: An Atomistic Insight at JoVE.com

The authors are grateful for the support from City University of Hong Kong Strategic Research Grant with the Project No. 7005547, the support from the Research Grants Council (RGC) of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China, with the&#160;Project No. R5007-18, and the support from Shenzhen Science and Technology Innovation Committee under the grant JCYJ20170818103206501.

1. Build the atomistic models
<ol>
	<li>Open the Materials Studio software to create five 3D atomistic documents and rename these documents as graphene, asphaltene, polar aromatics, naphthene aromatics, and saturates, respectively.</li>
	<li>Build the graphene model by creating the unit cell of graphene sheet in the 3D atomistic document using the Sketch Atom option.</li>
	<li>Construct the final structure using the Supercell option in the Build &#62; Symmetry menu. De...

The critical steps within the Protocol part are as follows: step 1.4 - Build and pack the four types of asphalt molecules; step 1.5 - Build the asphalt structure with the crack; step 2.3 - Achieve the equilibrium; step 2.4 - Perform the self-healing process. These steps indicate the most cohesive and important contents of the protocol. To create the desired shapes of the inserted crack, the packing process is modified compared to the normal packing in Materials Studio. The crack shape is created and filled inside the sim...

Deterioration under daily vehicle loadings and variant environmental conditions, and the aging of asphalt during service result in degradation or even structural failures, i.e., cracking and raveling, which can further weaken the durability of asphalt pavements. The inherent response of asphalt to repair micro-cracks and voids automatically helps it recover from damages and restore strength1. This self-healing capability can considerably extend the service life of asphalt, save costs on maintenance, and reduce the emission of greenhouse gases2,3. The self-healing behavior of asphalt generally depends on several influencing factors, including its chemical composition, the degree of damage, and environmental conditions4. The improved self-healing capability of asphalt that can fully heal damage within a short period is desired; this has attracted extensive research interest in better mechanical performance and durability for asphalt pavements within civil engineering.
Novel methods to improve the self-healing capability of asphalt mainly include three approaches - inducing heating, encapsulation healing, and incorporating nanomaterials - which can be applied individually or simultaneously5,6. Inducing heating can significantly improve the mobility of asphalt and activate its self-healing for recovery7. The self-healing technology of asphalt by inducing heating can be ascribed to the assisted self-healing technique, which indicates that the self-healing properties of asphalt are improved by external stimuli. The objective of adding the steel wool fibers is to enhance the electrical conductivity so as to increase the healing capacity of the asphalt binder8. The approach to induce heat is to expose these electrically conductive fibers to the high-frequency alternating electromagnetic field, which can induce eddy currents, and the heat energy can diffuse into the asphalt binder by the conductive fibers9. The steel wool fibers enhance not just the&#160;electrical conductivity&#160;but also the thermal conductivity, both of which can positively affect the self-healing properties of asphalt. However, it is challenging to select the proper mixing time for fibers10. The length of fibers decreases with increased mixing time and influences thermal conductivity, while the decreased mixing time leads to clusters of fibers and impedes the mechanical properties of asphalt9. The encapsulation method can supply light components of aged asphalt such as aromatics and saturates and refresh the self-healing capability of asphalt11,12. However, this is a once-only treatment, and the healing materials cannot be replenished after the release. With the development of nanotechnology, nanomaterials have become promising modifiers for enhancing asphalt-based materials. Asphalt binders incorporated with nanomaterials present better thermal conductivity and mechanical properties13. Graphene with excellent mechanical performance and high thermal performance is regarded as an excellent candidate to improve the self-healing ability of asphalt14,15,16,17. The increased healing properties of graphene-modified asphalt can be attributed to the fact that graphene increases the capacity of the asphalt binder to be heated and produce heat transfer inside the asphalt binder, which means that graphene-modified asphalt can be heated more rapidly and reach up to higher temperature than pure asphalt18. The generated heat can be transferred throughout the graphene-modified asphalt at a faster speed than that through pure asphalt. The crack region of the asphalt binder can be influenced easily and healed faster by the heat flow with higher temperature and higher heating capacity. The self-healing reaction will begin if the energy that is equal to or larger than the healing activation energy exists at the crack surface of the asphalt19. Graphene can improve the thermal activation healing performance and accelerate the healing rate of asphalt19,20. Besides, graphene can save heating energy&#160;up to 50% during the healing process, which can benefit energy efficiency and reduce maintenance costs21.&#160;As a microwave-absorbent material, graphene is reported to improve the healing ability of asphalt during the rest period of microwave heating22. It is expected that the addition of graphene into asphalt will improve not only the mechanical performance but also the self-healing and energy-saving capacity, which requires in-depth knowledge of the self-healing mechanism.
Self-healing at the nanoscale is mainly due to the wetting and diffusion of asphalt molecules at the fractured faces23. As asphalt consists of various polar and non-polar molecules, its self-healing capability is strongly related to molecular interactions and movements of&#160;asphalt molecules of different components1. However, current research mainly relies on experimental techniques to quantify macroscopic mechanical properties, which causes missing information in the change of microstructures and the interactions among asphalt molecules when trying to understand the healing mechanism. The reinforcing mechanism of graphene in the self-healing capability of asphalt is also unclear at this stage. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations play an influential role in investigating molecular interactions and motions of nanocomposite systems, and link microstructural deformation with molecular interactions and movements24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31. MD simulations have become more and more popular for analyzing material behaviors that cannot be accessed easily by experiments32,33. Existing studies have shown the feasibility and availability of MD simulations in asphalt systems; the cohesion, adhesion, aging, and thermomechanical properties of asphalt and asphalt composites can be explored by MD simulations34,35,36,37. The self-healing behaviors of asphalt can also be predicted by MD simulations38,39,40. Therefore, it is believed that the investigation using MD simulations is an effective way to understand both the self-healing and reinforcing mechanisms.
The objectives of this study are to investigate the self-healing behaviors of pure asphalt and graphene-modified asphalt nanocomposites and to understand the role of graphene in improving the healing capacity of asphalt through MD simulations. The self-healing simulations of pure asphalt and graphene-modified asphalt composites are carried out by introducing cracks into the initial structures. The self-healing capabilities are characterized by the contour of atom numbers, the reorientation and entanglement&#160;of molecules at the fractured face, and the mobility of asphalt components during the self-healing processes. By investigating the healing efficiency of graphene at different sites, the reinforcing mechanism of graphene contributing to the self-healing abilities of asphalt is unveiled, which can help with the monitoring of nanofillers in an optimal way and thus enable the life extension of asphalt pavements. An investigation of the self-healing capacity at the atomistic scale can provide an efficient way to develop advanced asphalt-based materials for future research.
According to asphalt chemistry, asphalt consists of various types of hydrocarbons and non-hydrocarbons with different polarity and shapes, which can mainly be divided into the four components of asphaltene, polar aromatics, naphthene aromatics, and saturates41,42. Asphaltene molecules are relatively larger and heavier than other molecules in asphalt, with a mean atomic mass of roughly 750 g/mol and a molecular diameter in the range of 10-20 &#197;. It has been widely accepted that asphaltene is composed of large aromatic cores that contain heteroatoms and are surrounded by different lengths of alkyl groups43. A modified asphaltene molecule is constructed, as shown in Figure 1a. The molecules of polar aromatics and naphthene aromatics are constructed based on the polarity and the element ratio of asphalt molecules, with benzobisbenzothiophene (C18H10S2) representing the polar aromatic molecule and 1,7-dimethylnaphthalene (C12H12) chosen as the representative naphthene aromatic molecule, as shown in Figure 1b-c. N-docosane (n-C22H46) is constructed as shown in Figure 1d. The parameters listed in Table 1 for asphalt molecules are selected and used to meet the desired criteria, including the elemental mass fraction, the atom ratio, and the aromatic/aliphatic ratio, of real asphalt from experiments41. The same mass ratio has been defined in our previous studies, and the other thermomechanical properties like density, glass transition temperature, and viscosity are in good agreement with experimental data of real asphalt36. The molecular structure of graphene applied in this study is shown in Figure 1e. The adopted graphene sheet in this study has no defect and no fold compared to that of the real case, while the real graphene sheet usually has several defects such as&#160;atomic vacancies and Stone-Wales defects44, and some of the graphene sheets can be folded during the mixing process in the asphalt matrix45. These imperfect situations are not considered in this study, since we focus on the effect of the site of the graphene sheet on the self-healing properties and choose it as the only variable. The variables of graphene sheets in terms of the defects and folded cases will be the focus of our future studies. The mass ratio of graphene to asphalt in this study is 4.75%, which is the normal situation (&#60;5%) for graphene modified asphalt in the experiment46,47.
<img alt="Figure 1" class="xfigimg" src="/files/ftp_upload/63303/63303fig01.jpg" /> 
Figure 1: Chemical structure. The atomistic models of (a) asphaltene molecule (C53H55NOS), (b) naphthene aromatic molecule (C12H12), (c) polar aromatic molecule (C18H10S2), (d) saturate molecule (C22H46), (e) graphene, and (f) pure asphalt. For the atomistic asphalt model, the carbon, oxygen, nitrogen, sulfur, and hydrogen atoms are shown in gray, red, blue, yellow, and white, respectively. <a href="https://www.jove.com/files/ftp_upload/63303/63303fig01large.jpg" target="_blank">Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.</a>
<table border="1" fo:keep-together.within-page="1" fo:keep-with-next.within-page="always">
	<tbody>
		<tr>
			<td>Asphalt model</td>
			<td>Mass (g/mol)</td>
			<td>Chemical formula</td>
			<td>Numbers of molecules</td>
			<td>Total mass (g/mol)</td>
			<td>Mass fraction (%)</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>Asphaltene</td>
			<td>754.04</td>
			<td>C53H55NOS</td>
			<td>43</td>
			<td>32423.72</td>
			<td>26</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>Naphthene aromatic</td>
			<td>156.22</td>
			<td>C12H12</td>
			<td>65</td>
			<td>10154.3</td>
			<td>8</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>Polar aromatic</td>
			<td>290.38</td>
			<td>C18H10S2</td>
			<td>74</td>
			<td>21485.16</td>
			<td>17</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>Saturate</td>
			<td>310.59</td>
			<td>C22H46</td>
			<td>205</td>
			<td>63670.95</td>
			<td>49</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>Asphalt binder</td>
			<td></td>
			<td></td>
			<td>387</td>
			<td>127734.13</td>
			<td>100</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>Graphene</td>
			<td>6369.28</td>
			<td>C525H63</td>
			<td>1</td>
			<td>6369.28</td>
			<td></td>
		</tr>
	</tbody>
</table>
Table 1: Overall components of pure asphalt model and graphene-modified asphalt model.
With respect to the protocol described below, two types of wedge-like cracks with different sizes are inserted into the middle of the asphalt model with a blunt crack tip and two parallel crack surfaces, while the middle-top area of the asphalt bulk remains intact. Two crack widths are chosen as 15 &#197; and 35 &#197;, as shown in Figure 2a-b. The reason for selecting 15 &#197; is that the crack width should be wider than the cutoff of 12 &#197; to avoid the early self-healing of asphalt molecules during the equilibrium process while investigating an extreme case for a small crack. The reason for selecting 35 &#197; is that the crack width should be wider than the length of the saturate molecules of 34 &#197; in order to prevent the bridging effect. The height of the crack is 35 &#197;, the same as the box width, and the depth of the crack is 70 &#197;, the same as the box length. In the real situation, the observed micro-crack sizes can be varied in the range from several micrometers to several millimeters, which is far larger than the length scale we are modeling here. Normally, the length scale in MD simulation is limited to the scale of 100 nm, which is still several orders of magnitude smaller than the real crack size. However, the cracks initiate at the nanoscale and grow into macroscale cracks with continuous deformation48. The understanding of the self-healing mechanism at the nanoscale can help to prevent the growth and further propagation of the crack at the macroscale. Even though the selected crack sizes are in the range of nanometer, the results can still be influential and applicable to explore the self-healing behaviors of asphalt molecules. There are two locations for the graphene sheets in the crack areas: one is on top of the crack tip and the other is perpendicular to the left crack surface. It has been found that these are the most common positions for graphene in graphene-modified nanocomposites with cracks49.
<img alt="Figure 2" class="xfigimg" src="/files/ftp_upload/63303/63303fig02.jpg" /> 
Figure 2: The self-healing schemes for pure asphalt and graphene-modified asphalt. The self-healing model of pure asphalt with a crack width of (a) 15&#160;&#197; and (b) 35 &#197;. The self-healing model of graphene-modified asphalt with the graphene sheet is located (c) at the top of the crack tip and (d) perpendicular to the crack surface. <a href="https://www.jove.com/files/ftp_upload/63303/63303fig02large.jpg" target="_blank">Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.</a>
In MD simulations, the intramolecular and intermolecular interactions in the asphalt nanocomposites are described by the Consistent Valence Forcefield (CVFF)50, which works well with asphalt and graphene-based materials. The functional form of CVFF is expressed as&#160;the following expression:
<img alt="Equation 1" src="/files/ftp_upload/63303/63303eq01v2.jpg" /> 1
Here, the total energy Etotal is composed of the bonded energy terms and the non-bonded energy terms. The bonded interactions consist of the covalent bond stretching, the bond angle bending energy, the torsion angle rotation, and the improper energies as expressed in the first four terms. The non-bonded energy includes an LJ-12-6 function for the van der Waals (vdW) term and a Coulombic function for the electrostatic interactions. CVFF has been widely employed in simulating asphalt materials51,52. The simulated physical and mechanical properties such as density, viscosity, and bulk modulus are in good agreement with the experimental data, which demonstrates the reliability of CVFF51. CVFF is not only suitable for inorganic materials, but it has also been successfully employed in structures consisting of organic and inorganic phases such as asphalt-silica52 and the system of epoxy-graphene53. In addition, the interfacial interactions between graphene and asphalt can be characterized by CVFF36,54. Since the major part in selecting forcefield is to determine the asphalt-graphene interface, the non-bonded interactions described by CVFF are more reliable, which is also considered in our previous study36. Overall, the forcefield CVFF is adopted in this study.&#160;The partial charges for different kinds of atoms are calculated by the forcefield-assigned method.

<table border="1" fo:keep-together.within-page="1" fo:keep-with-next.within-page="always">
	<tbody>
		<tr>
			<td>Atomistic models of asphalt and graphene/Materials Studio</td>
			<td>BIOVIA</td>
			<td>Materials Studio 8.0</td>
			<td>The atomistic models are built for molecular dynamics simulations.</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>Large-scale Atomic/Molecular Massively Parallel Simulator Package</td>
			<td>Sandia National Laboratories</td>
			<td>lammps-stable20</td>
			<td>The equilibrium is achieved under NPT ensemble, and the atomistic models get self-healed.</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>OVITO</td>
			<td>Materials Science Department of Technische Universit&#228;t Darmstadt, Germany</td>
			<td>ovito-basic-3.1.0-win64</td>
			<td>The self-healing behaviors of the atomistic models are visualized.</td>
		</tr>
		<tr>
			<td>Origin</td>
			<td>OriginLab</td>
			<td>Origin 2018 64Bit</td>
			<td>The contours of the atom numbers of the trajectory are drawn and analyzed.</td>
		</tr>
	</tbody>
</table>

advanced self-healing asphalt reinforced by graphene structures: an atomistic insight

Graphene can improve the self-healing properties of asphalt with high durability. However, the self-healing behaviors of graphene-modified asphalt nanocomposite and the role of incorporated graphene are still unclear at this stage. In this study, the self-healing properties of pure asphalt and graphene-modified asphalt are investigated through molecular dynamics simulations. Asphalt bulks with two crack widths and locations for graphene are introduced, and the molecular interactions among asphalt components and the graphene sheet are analyzed. The results show that the location of graphene significantly affects the self-healing behaviors of asphalt. Graphene near the crack surface can greatly accelerate the self-healing process by interacting with the aromatic molecules through &#960;-&#960; stacking, while graphene at the top area of the crack tip has a minor impact on the process. The self-healing process of asphalt goes through the reorientation of asphaltene, polar aromatic, and naphthene aromatic molecules, and the bridging of saturate molecules between crack surfaces. This in-depth understanding of the self-healing mechanism contributes to the knowledge of the enhancement for self-healing properties, which will help to develop durable asphalt pavements.

The contour of atom number 
The contours of the atom number of pure asphalt and graphene-modified asphalt models in the yz plane are shown in Figure 3, where the color bar from blue to red exhibits atom numbers varying from 0 to 28. Figure 3a-c illustrates the contour of the atom number of the structures with 15 &#197; crack width in pure asphalt and asphalt nanocomposites modified by graphene at the crack ...

Watch this Scientific Journal Video about Advanced Self-Healing Asphalt Reinforced by Graphene Structures: An Atomistic Insight at JoVE.com

Advanced Self-Healing Asphalt Reinforced by Graphene Structures: An Atomistic Insight

Graphene-modified asphalt nanocomposite has shown an advanced self-healing ability compared to pure asphalt. In this protocol, molecular dynamics simulations have been applied in order to understand the role of graphene in the self-healing process and to explore the self-healing mechanism of asphalt components from the atomistic level.

Graphene can improve the self-healing properties of asphalt with high durability. However, the self-healing behaviors of graphene-modified asphalt ...

This method can help answer whole crack self-heals in asphalt based the nano composites, and how graphite can improve the capacity of asphalts. This technique can analyze material behaviors that cannot be assessed easily by experiments, and can provide the underlying information about the self-healing mechanism at an atomistic level. This method could provide insights into fundamental physics of dynamic evolution in various material systems including inorgi-inorganic systems and related interfaces, or even gaze at electro molecules.If unfamiliar with this technique, one should understand the basic theory of molecule dynamic simulations and figured out the basic meaning of each command before carrying out any simulations. To begin open the material studio software, then create a three dimensional atomistic document for graphine and build the graphine model using the sketch atom option. After importing the graphite dot MSI file into material studio, in the build menu under symmetry, construct the final structure using the super cell option.Define the size of the graphine sheet as 40 by 40 angstroms, which is larger than the asphalt chains in the crack width. Next, to build and pack the four types of asphalt molecules, create the three dimensional atomistic documents for asphaltene, polar aromatics, napthene aromatics and saturates separately. Then using the sketch atom option, draw the molecular structures of these molecules.Next, using the calculation option from the amorphous cell menu under modules, pack these four kinds of asphalt molecules into the simulation box. Then, to build the asphalt structure with the crack, set the height of the crack zone in the X dimension, same as the height of the box of 70 angstroms, and set the depth of the crack zone in the Y dimension to half of the height of the box as 35 angstroms. Set two cases of the crack widths in the Z dimension of 15 and 35 angstroms.Then, using the delete option, delete the redundant molecules in the crack zones of the middle down area of asphalt bulk, and keep the asphalt matrix in the middle up area unchanged. To achieve equilibrium, place the whole simulation box fully relaxed after 500 picoseconds under the isothermal isobaric ensemble with a temperature of 300 Kelvin in pressure of 1 atmosphere. Then, using the thermal command, equilibrate the asphalt bulk to the desired density value of the experimental measurements by continuously examining the temperature, pressure, density, and energy values.Check the convergence of potential energy in the mean squared displacement in the whole system for achieving the fully relaxed state. Next, to perform the self-healing process, set the whole simulation box under the isothermal isobaric ensemble with a temperature of 300 Kelvin and pressure of 1 atmosphere. Then, remove the constraint of the asphalt molecules on the contour of the crack zone.Track and record the size of the simulation box in the coordinates of the atoms. Then, use the dump command for post processing. Finally, average the simulation results during the self-healing process over 3 independent configurations with 3 different initial velocity seeds to decrease the random errors.For visualizing the self-healing behaviors and simulation progress, open the open visualization tool OVITO"then, open the trajectory files in the LAMMPS TRJ format generated by LAMMPS. Record the snapshots of the self-healing process, then, using the render command, track the paths of the asphalt molecules. Next, to analyze the contour of the atom number, export the coordinates of the atoms from the trajectory files to the data analysis and graphing software.Project the coordinates of the atoms in the whole system onto the YZ plane, then record atom numbers at different areas of the YZ plane and plot the contour with different colors. Next, analyze the atom mobility of different asphalt components by calculating the mean squared displacement using the compute MSD command. Then using the compute RDF command and LAMMPS, calculate the relative positions between the graphine and asphalt molecules by the radial distribution factor, or RDF curves, for the graphing modified asphalt systems with the 15 and 35 angstrom crack widths.Finally, draw the RDF curves to check how the density of asphalt varies as a function of distance from the graphine sheet. For pure asphalt, complete self-healing occurs after 300 picoseconds. The crack zone sharply decreases at 50, almost disappears at 200 picoseconds.Inserting the graphine on the left of the crack surface can significantly accelerate the self-healing process. The healing period shortens to 200 picoseconds, with the crack width significantly decreasing at 20, and almost disappearing at around 150 picoseconds. The self-healing behaviors significantly improved when the graphine sheet is at the left crack surface.When graphine is placed at the left crack surface, the mobilities of polar aromatics, napthene aromatics, and graphine improved significantly compared to that of pure asphalt. RDF values between graphine at the left crack surface in the asphalt components for the 15 angstrom crack width model show that the aromatic molecules and asphalt move closer to the graphine sheet, especially the polar aromatic molecules and napthene aromatic molecules. Where the 35 angstrom crack width model RDF values beyond 4 angstroms are more obvious than those of the 15 angstrom crack width model because asphaltite has more space to diffuse and move toward the graphine in the larger crack zone.It is very important to set a reasonable crack in the asphalt model while ensuring that a crack is well kept and the system is fully equilibrated. Cost grain modeling can be performed based on this procedure to embrace a broader range of length scale, and further is brought, the self healing of crack in asphalt at different scales. This technique can monitor and optimize the molecular structure of nano fillers with special design, such as defects, photo structure and functional groups for advanced improvement of asphalt based nano composites.

Research

JoVE Journal

Engineering

Synthesis and Functionalization of 3D Nano-graphene Materials: Graphene Aerogels and Graphene Macro Assemblies

Efforts to assemble graphene into three-dimensional monolithic structures have been hampered by the high cost and poor processability of graphene. ...

Integration of Light Trapping Silver Nanostructures in Hydrogenated Microcrystalline Silicon Solar Cells by Transfer Printing

One of the potential applications of metal nanostructures is light trapping in solar cells, where unique optical properties of nanosized metals, commonly ...

Preparation of ZnO Nanorod/Graphene/ZnO Nanorod Epitaxial Double Heterostructure for Piezoelectrical Nanogenerator by Using Preheating Hydrothermal

Well-aligned ZnO nanostructures have been intensively studied over the last decade for remarkable physical properties and enormous applications. Here, we ...

Strain Sensing Based on Multiscale Composite Materials Reinforced with Graphene Nanoplatelets

The electrical response of NH2-functionalized graphene nanoplatelets composite materials under strain was studied. Two different manufacturing methods are ...

Scanning SQUID Study of Vortex Manipulation by Local Contact

Local, deterministic manipulation of individual vortices in type 2 superconductors is challenging. The ability to control the position of individual ...

Experimental Protocol to Determine the Chloride Threshold Value for Corrosion in Samples Taken from Reinforced Concrete Structures

The aging of reinforced concrete infrastructure in developed countries imposes an urgent need for methods to reliably assess the condition of these ...

Atmospheric Pressure Fabrication of Large-Sized Single-Layer Rectangular SnSe Flakes

Tin selenide (SnSe) belongs to the family of layered metal chalcogenide materials with a buckled structure like phosphorene, and has shown potential for ...

An Efficient Method for Selective Desalination of Radioactive Iodine Anions by Using Gold Nanoparticles-Embedded Membrane Filter

Here, we demonstrate a detail protocol for the preparation of nanomaterials-embedded composite membranes and its application to the efficient and ...

Multiscale Structures Aggregated by Imprinted Nanofibers for Functional Surfaces

Multiscale surface structures have attracted increasing interest owing to several potential applications in surface devices. However, an existing ...

Preparation of Graphene Liquid Cells for the Observation of Lithium-ion Battery Material

In this work, we introduce the preparation of graphene liquid cells (GLCs), encapsulating both electrode materials and organic liquid electrolytes between ...