feeding and tending the kiln for quantifying and characterizing the biochar

Carbon Sequestration and Soil Enhancement Through Onsite Biochar Production

In many world regions, including the western US, climate change, drought, and alien invasive species have created a wildfire crisis that threatens ecosystems and communities. As forests and woodlands burn uncontrollably, large amounts of particulates and greenhouse gasses are emitted into the atmosphere, with devastating consequences for human health and the climate. For instance, wildfires in California in 2020 are estimated to have released around 127 million megatons of greenhouse gas emissions, approximately two times the amount of California&#39;s total GHG emission reductions from 2003 to 20191. Increasingly, scientists and land managers are investigating human actions that can help restore these forests and woodlands and their ecosystem services. The manual thinning and removal of excess biomass is one of the most important actions that must be taken2. Removal of biomass includes its disposal, and where the biomass is situated in remote and difficult-to-access locations, there are few options other than incineration onsite in unmanaged slash piles. Unmanaged burn piles do the job of removing fuels from the landscape, but they damage forest soils as the concentrated heat under the piles incinerates the soil&#39;s organic horizon, leaving behind bare soil that is vulnerable to erosion and colonization by invasive species. It can take decades to regenerate the organic soil horizon in a burn pile scar3. Unmanaged burn piles are also a source of particulate and greenhouse gas emissions. Smoke from slash pile burning also restricts the burning window in air-quality-limited watersheds, making it more difficult to accomplish the work.
Researchers for the USDA Forest Service have examined the alternative of producing biochar from slash materials, and have identified several promising techniques, including the option of using small, mobile biochar kilns in the forest4. Converting forest slash to biochar onsite has many ecological advantages over the current practice of slash disposal by incineration in burn piles, including reduced soil heating and particulate emissions. Biochar produced onsite can be removed and utilized in agriculture, or it can be left in place where it serves several functions in restoring forest health and improving adaptation to climate change and drought. Because up to 50% of the total carbon in many forest soils is charcoal from historic, natural fires5, leaving biochar on the site where it is made can restore forest soil charcoal that is often missing from recent soil horizons due to fire suppression, with unknown impacts on ecosystem processes6. Biochar left in place on forest soils can mimic the effects of charcoal produced by natural fire and produce similar effects on soil carbon content and soil physical, chemical and biological properties7.
In recent years, an international network of forestry workers, woodland owners, researchers, and biochar consultants has developed a suite of carbonization methods for converting forest slash into biochar onsite as an alternative to slash pile incineration. These methods are based on the principle of flame carbonization, first developed and commercialized in Japan as the &#34;smokeless carbonizing kiln&#34; offered by the Moki company8. This steel ring kiln makes well-carbonized biochar with reported biomass-to-biochar conversion efficiency of 13% to 20%, depending on the feedstock used9.
The process of producing biochar or charcoal is often referred to as pyrolysis, the separation of biomass components by heat in the absence of oxygen. This is usually conceived of as retort pyrolysis, where biomass is physically isolated from air in an externally heated vessel. However, pyrolysis can also take place in the presence of limited air, as in gasification and flame carbonization, because solid fuels like wood burn in stages. When heat is applied to biomass, the first stage of combustion is dehydration, as water is evaporated from the material. This is followed by devolatilization and simultaneous char formation, also known as pyrolysis. Volatile gas containing hydrogen and oxygen is released and burned in a flame, continually adding heat to the process. As the gas is released, the remaining carbon is converted to aromatic carbon, or char. The final stage of combustion is the oxidation of the char to mineral ash10.
Because these are discrete phases that occur in an open combustion process, we have the opportunity to stop the process after char formation by removing air or heat. This is accomplished during the biochar production process by continually adding new material to the burn pile so that the hot char is buried by new material that cuts off the flow of oxygen. Hot charcoal accumulates in the bottom of the pile and is prevented from burning to ash as long as flame is present, because the flame consumes most of the available oxygen. When all of the fuel has been added to the pile, the flame begins to die down. At that point, the hot charcoal can be preserved by removing oxygen and heat, usually by spraying the coals with water and raking them thin to cool11.
The basic principle of operation is that of counter-flow combustion. Counter-flow combustion air keeps the flame low and prevents the emission of embers or sparks. The flame also burns most of the smoke, reducing emissions. In summary, the following principles explain the operation of counter-flow combustion in a flame cap kiln: (1) Gas flows upward while combustion air flows downward, (2) Counter-current flow is established as burning fuel draws air downward, (3) Flames stay low and close to fuel, minimizing&#160;ember escape, (4) Smoke burns in the hot zone, (5) Because all the combustion air comes from above, it is consumed by the flames (6) Very little air is able to reach the unburned coals that fall to the bottom of the kiln, (7) The coals are preserved until the end of the process when they are quenched or snuffed.
In addition to its benefits to soil, biochar is also a leading method of carbon removal for climate change mitigation. Up to half the carbon in woody biomass can be converted to stable, aromatic carbon in the form of biochar12. However, not all pyrolysis technologies produce the same amount of recalcitrant carbon that remains stable in soils for 100 years or more (the key metric for determining carbon removal value). Biochar stability is closely correlated with the temperature of production. The adiabatic flame temperature of burning wood is estimated to be close to that of propane, 1,977 &#176;C13. Biochar production in a flame cap kiln is closely coupled with the flame, with no heat transfer losses by conduction through a metal wall, as in retort pyrolysis. Therefore, we would expect that the temperature of production would be high as long as a flame is maintained during the process. A survey of chars using Raman spectroscopy14 reported that a biochar sample from a flame cap kiln (provided by lead author Kelpie Wilson) was among the three samples with the highest apparent temperature of char formation, in the range of 900 &#176;C.
Thermocouples are required to access the interior of the burn and accurately measure the production temperature of biochar in a flame cap kiln or burn pile, and these are expensive and not available to low-tech producers. Therefore, we have used a method described by researchers working in the Brazilian Amazon that uses heat crayons&#160;(used by welders to check the temperature of metal parts) that melt at a calibrated temperature15. Bricks are marked with crayons, wrapped in aluminum foil, and placed in various places in the kiln during production. We used this method several times and determined that the kiln temperatures exceeded 650&#176; C, as the crayon marks were completely melted. This will be a useful method to confirm production temperatures where needed; however, the main verification point will be documenting the presence of flame throughout.
There is not much published data on the characteristics of biochar made by low-tech flame carbonizing methods. However, biochar samples made by flame carbonizing methods in several kiln types were analyzed by Cornellissen et al. and found to meet European Biochar Certificate (EBC) standards for biochar, including low PAH content and high biochar stability. Furthermore, the biochar produced from both woody and herbaceous feedstocks had an average carbon content of 76 percent11. The US Forest Service Rocky Mountain Research Station16&#160;analyzed five biochar samples from flame cap kilns and burn piles made at a field day in California in 2022. The average carbon content of the samples was 85 percent. Given these results, we can conclude that it is likely that biochar made from woody residues in flame cap kilns will meet the basic requirements for verified carbon removal: high carbon content and high biochar stability.
Two carbon removal protocols for low-tech, place-based biochar production have now been released by Verra17 and the European Biochar Consortium Global Artisan C-Sink protocol18. These newly developed protocols are promising; however, they have some limitations when applied to forests, woodland, and other landscapes under threat from drought and wildfire. Accordingly, this paper will describe a new methodology, the Methodology CM002 V1.0, from AD Tech19, that is being developed specifically for flame carbonization of woody debris as part of vegetation management and fuel load reduction activities. Life cycle analysis confirms that biochar carbon sequestration using onsite biochar production from woody biomass in flame cap kilns produces a net carbon removal benefit20. Successful implementation of carbon removal protocols can help support financially the vital fuels reduction work that needs to take place to protect communities and ecosystems from wildfires and ecosystem degradation. In order to access carbon removal payments, field measurements and digital monitoring, reporting and verification (D-MRV) methods are incorporated as routine practices into the biochar production methodology described here. Details of the platform are discussed in the Supplemental Information (Supplementary File 1).
While several open-source designs of flame cap kilns are being manufactured by individuals for their own use21, to our knowledge, at this time, there is only one flame cap kiln with a capacity of greater than one cubic meter that is being mass produced for sale in North America, the Ring of Fire Kiln22, a lightweight, portable flame cap kiln that is designed for easy mobility using hand crews. The kiln consists of an inner ring comprising six sheets of mild steel secured together. An outer ring composed of lighter gauge steel bolts onto the brackets that hold the inner ring together. The outer ring serves as a heat shield that holds in heat for better efficiency. The top of the kiln is open to the air, and this is where the flame cap forms. Air flowing up through the annular gap between the main kiln body and the heat shield provides pre-heated combustion air to the kiln, further increasing combustion efficiency (Figure 1)
<img alt="Figure 1" class="xfigimg" src="/files/ftp_upload/65543/65543fig01.jpg" /> 
Figure 1: Schematic showing air flow, flame characteristics, and char accumulation in the Ring of Fire Kiln. Counter-flow combustion air pulls the smoke into the hot zone, where it burns up. Air flowing up through the annular gap between the main kiln body and the heat shield provides pre-heated combustion air to the kiln, further increasing combustion efficiency. <a href="https://www.jove.com/files/ftp_upload/65543/65543fig01large.jpg" target="_blank">Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.</a>
The kiln diameter is 2.35 m, forming a cylinder that is one meter tall for a total volume of 4.3 m3. In practice, the kiln is never filled completely to the top, so a typical production batch will fill the kiln from between &#189; to &#190; full for a volume of biochar that is between 2 and 3 cubic meters.
Because the Ring of Fire Kiln is a standardized design, it is being adopted as the first certified technology for use in the CM002 Component Methodology that provides standardized procedures for the quantification of greenhouse gas (GHG) benefits. Measurement and data collection steps meeting the requirements of the CM002 are incorporated into the method. Reporting is done through a smartphone application by answering short questionnaires throughout the process and uploading photos and video clips to the mobile app.

Author Spotlight: On-Site Biochar Production for Woody Debris Incineration in Forestry 

Producing, Characterizing and Quantifying Biochar in the Woods Using Portable Flame Cap Kilns

We're looking for solutions to the problem of woody debris incineration in forestry. We hope to develop methods for making biochar on-site using simple technologies that are cost effective and quantifiable for determining carbon sequestration value. New technologies are being developed to make biochar in places where biomass accumulates to avoid high transportation costs.These technologies include mechanized air curtain burners and simple containers that are fed by hand labor or by machine. These techniques work on the principle of flame carbonization. To pay the cost of making biochar, we can apply for carbon removal credits, but quantifying the amount of biochar made under field conditions is challenging.We need appropriate carbon accounting protocols and methods for monitoring, reporting, and verification. Methods for quantifying biochar production in the field using simple techniques have not been well developed. This protocol provides the first steps toward robust and repeatable measurement techniques.Our carbon accounting protocol for field verification of biochar production provides detailed information that is verified with visual evidence obtained throughout the production process. Other existing protocols have fewer controls and rely more on estimates and safety factors. Our protocol maximizes benefits for those who are doing the work.

Watch this Scientific Journal Video about Feeding and Tending the Kiln for Quantifying and Characterizing the Biochar at JoVE.com

Feeding and Tending the Kiln for Quantifying and Characterizing the Biochar  

Begin by loading and lighting the kiln. Ensure the first load generates a solid bed of coals before adding more material. Once the previous layer starts to display a film of white ash, load new material in the kiln at a steady rate.Monitor the flame closely as it guides the addition of new material, and always maintain a robust flame on top. One hour after the kiln ignition, launch the DMRV application. Proceed to the Burn Quality Proof section, and choose the Proof of Burn At First Hour button.Select the Take Video option, and record the video for at least 30 seconds. Then, click the Submit Video button. Place the largest material during the mid stages of the burn to ensure it chars completely.After the second hour of burning, record a 30-second video of the flame by clicking the Proof of Burn At Second Hour using the DMRV application, and submit it as shown previously. Similarly, at the end of the third hour of the burn, click the Proof of Burn At Third Hour on the application, and initiate a 30-second video of the flame. In the final stages, when the kiln is filled with red hot glowing coals, arrange the last few layers with medium-sized material to allow larger pieces to complete their charring process.

feeding-tending-kiln-for-quantifying-characterizing

Research

JoVE Journal

Environment

368 Views.  US Biochar Initiative. Begin by loading and lighting the kiln. Ensure the first load generates a solid bed of coals before adding more material. Once the previous layer starts to display a film of white ash, load new material in the kiln at a steady rate.Monitor the flame closely as it guides the addition of new material, and always maintain a robust flame on top. One hour after the kiln ignition, launch the DMRV application. Proceed to the Burn Quality Proof section, and choose the Proof of Burn At First Ho...

Video: Feeding and Tending the Kiln for Quantifying and Characterizing the Biochar  

One of the biggest challenges in utilizing non-commercial forest biomass is its widely distributed nature. The best solution to the biomass problem, to avoid expensive and carbon-intensive processing (chipping) and transportation costs, is to process it onsite. However, conventional burn piles have destructive impacts on forest soil and provide no benefits other than fuel reduction. Converting forest slash to biochar onsite has many ecological advantages over the current practice of slash disposal by incineration in burn piles, including reduced soil heating and particulate emissions, along with multiple benefits of the biochar to forest soil health and water holding capacity when left in place. Making biochar onsite in the woods is a way to return a pyrogenic carbon component to forest soils that has been missing due to the recent history of fire suppression. Biochar is also a leading method of carbon removal and sequestration for climate change mitigation. In this study, we document a method for making biochar using a portable biochar kiln. This low-cost method utilizes hand crews equipped with water for quenching kilns before the biochar burns to ash. Simple techniques for quantifying and characterizing the biochar produced are incorporated into the method for the purpose of measuring impact and qualifying for carbon removal certificates to help pay for the cost of the work. We describe the CM002 Component Methodology that provides standardized procedures for the quantification of GHG benefits during three stages of the process: waste biomass sourcing, biochar production, and biochar soil application. The CM002 Methodology is based on international best practices, including the most recent VCS methodology VM0044 Standards and EBC C-Sink Artisan Standards. Reliable quantification methods utilizing appropriate safety factors are the first essential step toward eligibility for carbon removal finance.

New methods for disposing of forestry slash piles in place produce pyrogenic carbon for restoring forest soil health and for carbon removal and sequestration. Here, we present a biochar production method integrating a new carbon removal accounting methodology and a digital application.

One of the biggest challenges in utilizing non-commercial forest biomass is its widely distributed nature. The best solution to the biomass problem, to ...

Assembling, Loading, and Lighting the Kiln for Biochar Production 

To begin, select and note down the size of the feedstock. Choose wood material less than 15 centimeters in diameter. Launch the dMRV application and click the Take A Photo button under the feedstock section to activate the camera.Carefully align the camera to capture the subject, and click the shutter button on the display. To measure the largest piece of each feedstock type, use a firewood moisture meter to pierce the middle with its pins. Afterward, go to the dMRV application and select the Take A Photo button under the moisture meter section.Input the value displayed from the moisture meter reading into the provided text field. Clear flammable organic material from a three meter diameter circle on level ground. Assemble the six inner kiln panels into a cylinder using the connector brackets and use a shovel to seal the bottom edge of the cylinder with a small berm made of mineral, dirt, or clay.Then attach the six heat shield panels to the connector brackets. Securely attach the kiln ID tag to the heat shield using the heat shield hardware. Identify the kilns used in the batch.Then go to the burn preparation section and use the Take A Photo feature to capture images of the assembled kiln and its attached ID tag. Now, identify smaller dry material for the initial kiln loading. Carefully pack this material up to the brim of the kiln, saving any larger diameter material for after the first hour of the burn.Add small dry kindling material to the top of the loaded kiln. Use an accelerant if necessary and light the top of the kiln in multiple places using a match or fire starter. Once the flame cap is established, navigate to the Burn Start section of the dMRV application.Click the Take Photo button, followed by the Submit Photo button to capture a photo.

Finishing, Quenching, and Measuring the Biochar Produced from the Kiln

To start, load and ignite the kiln and let it burn until it's filled with glowing red coals. Once the biochar reaches 10 to 20 centimeters from the top, stop burning the kiln. Let the flame die down for 10 to 15 minutes after adding the last feed stock.Position a measuring stick vertically against the kiln wall, ensuring one end contacts the level char. In the DMRV application, navigate to the Measuring the Biochar section and click the Take a Photo button to illustrate the char's depth inside the kiln. Next, locate the text input field labeled What is the reading from the top of the biochar to the top of kiln?And enter the corresponding value indicated on the measuring stick. Repeat the measurement and photo recording two times at varied kiln locations by clicking the Submit and Add Another Photo button. After the char depth measurements have been reported, capture an image of the kiln ID tag for proof.Upon completion of the biochar batch, shovel hot glowing coals from the kiln into a metal bucket before initiating the quenching process. After determining the tear weight, use the hanging scale to get the weight of the coals and take a picture to record the weight. Gently spray water into the kiln until the heat shield is touchable.Remove all the heat shield panels and stack them away from the workspace. While spraying water, remove a few kiln panels and disperse the char into a thin layer to trigger cooling. Remove any partially charred pieces and arrange them on one of the kiln panels in a single layer with the measuring stick laid alongside.Using the DMRV application, take a picture of the incomplete charred pieces.