A Robotic Platform to Study the Foreflipper of the California Sea Lion

Summary

A robotic platform is described that will be used to study the hydrodynamic performance—forces and flowfields—of the swimming California sea lion. The robot is a model of the animal's foreflipper that is actuated by motors to replicate the motion of its propulsive stroke (the 'clap').

Abstract

The California sea lion (Zalophus californianus), is an agile and powerful swimmer. Unlike many successful swimmers (dolphins, tuna), they generate most of their thrust with their large foreflippers. This protocol describes a robotic platform designed to study the hydrodynamic performance of the swimming California sea lion (Zalophus californianus). The robot is a model of the animal's foreflipper that is actuated by motors to replicate the motion of its propulsive stroke (the 'clap'). The kinematics of the sea lion's propulsive stroke are extracted from video data of unmarked, non-research sea lions at the Smithsonian Zoological Park (SNZ). Those data form the basis of the actuation motion of the robotic flipper presented here. The geometry of the robotic flipper is based a on high-resolution laser scan of a foreflipper of an adult female sea lion, scaled to about 60% of the full-scale flipper. The articulated model has three joints, mimicking the elbow, wrist and knuckle joint of the sea lion foreflipper. The robotic platform matches dynamics properties—Reynolds number and tip speed—of the animal when accelerating from rest. The robotic flipper can be used to determine the performance (forces and torques) and resulting flowfields.

Introduction

While scientists have investigated the basic characteristics of sea lion swimming (energetics, cost of transport, drag coefficient, linear speed and acceleration^1-3, we lack information about the fluid dynamics of the system. Without this knowledge, we limit potential high-speed, high-maneuverability engineering applications to body-caudal fin (BCF) locomotion models⁴. By characterizing a different swimming paradigm, we hope to expand our catalog of design tools, specifically those with the potential to enable quieter, stealthier forms of swimming. Thus, we study the fundamental mechanism of sea lion swimming through direct observation of the California sea lion and laboratory investigations using a robotic sea lion foreflipper^5,6 .

To do this, we will employ a commonly used technique for exploring complex biological systems: a robotic platform⁷. Several locomotion studies—both of walking^8,9 and swimming¹⁰—have been based on either complex¹¹ or highly simplified¹² mechanical models of animals. Typically, the robotic platforms retain the essence of the model system, while allowing researchers to explore large parameter spaces^13-15. While not always characterizing the entire system, much is learned through these platforms that isolate a single component of a locomotive system. For example, the fundamental functioning of unsteady propulsors, like the back-and-forth sweeping of a caudal fin during carangiform swimming, has been intensely explored through experimental investigations of pitching and/or heaving panels^12,16,17,18. In this case, we can isolate certain modes of this complex motion in ways that animal based studies cannot. Those fundamental aspects of propulsion can then be used in the design of vehicles which do not need the biological complexity evolution provides.

In this paper, we present a novel platform for exploring the 'clap' phase of the sea lion thrust-producing stroke. Only a single foreflipper—the 'roboflipper'—is included in the platform. Its geometry is derived exactly from biological scans of a California sea lion (Zalophus californianus) specimen. The roboflipper is actuated to replicate the motion of the animals' derived from previous studies¹. This robotic flipper will be used to investigate the hydrodynamic performance of the swimming sea lion and to explore a wider parameter space than animal studies, particularly those of large aquatic mammals, can yield.

Protocol

1. Digitize a Specimen of a Sea Lion Foreflipper

1. Scan a specimen of a Sea lion foreflipper.
   1. Obtain a specimen of a sea lion flipper from a deceased individual (Figure 1a).
      NOTE: In our case, they were obtained from the Smithsonian Zoological Park in Washington, D.C.
   2. Hang the foreflipper vertically from its base (where the foreflipper attaches to the animal's body). This both allows the flipper to be straight when scanned, and exposes the entire surface for scanning.
   3. Scan flipper using a high-resolution structured light scanner, with an accuracy of approximately 0.5 mm, and error of approximately 0.1 mm (Figure 1b).
2. Import the point cloud into CAD software and render it as a surface. To do this, click 'Open' and select the desired .obj file. Click on 'Import' to import the file into the CAD software.
3. Manipulate the resulting point cloud using a computer-aided design (CAD) software by clicking on 'Extruded cut' and cutting out the flesh part (unwanted part) of the scan. Next, click on 'Scale' to obtain the appropriate scaling for the robotic flipper (68% of the full size). Inspect flipper for sufficient detail capture by comparing to the original specimen (Figure 2).
4. Create the mold around the flipper.
   1. In a CAD software, use the flipper surfaces to form a mold by creating a surrounding volume around the flipper surface. Do this by extruding a rectangular block by clicking on 'Sketch' to draw a rectangle and then extruding it to more than the height of the flipper to completely encompass it.
   2. Click on 'Assembly' and import both parts (flipper and rectangular block) into the working area. Click on 'Mate' and make the front and top plane of both the flipper and mold as coincident. This automatically places the flipper inside the mold.
   3. Select the mold from the design tree and click 'Edit Part'. Once the part is selected, click on 'Insert>Features>Cavity' to make a cavity of the flipper inside the mold. Sketch a line at the center of the rectangular mold and click on 'Split' to form two parts of the same mold.
   4. Click on 'Cut Part' to separate the surrounding volume into two parts for easy flipper extraction. Insert cavities and pegs on each half of the volume and save it as part one and two of the flipper mold (Figure 3).
   5. Convert the '.SLDRPT' files of the mold to '.STL'. Import these files to the proprietary software of the 3D printer and click on 'Print' to generate the 3D printed mold.

2. Design the Bone Structure

1. Open the digital foreflipper in a CAD software and obtain an image of the Sea lion foreflipper bone structure for reference (such as Figure 1 in English, 1977¹⁹).
2. Design three different pieces that mimic the bone structure that will fit inside the digital model of the foreflipper. Throughout this procedure, 'base' refers to the end of a part closer to the base of the foreflipper and 'tip' refers to the end of the part closer to the tip of the foreflipper.
   1. Base Piece
      1. Make the length of this piece proportional to the distance between the shoulder joint and the wrist of the Sea lion flipper (measurements are obtained using measuring tape). Do this using a CAD software by clicking on 'Sketch' and designing the shape of the base piece (Figure 4).
      2. Add knuckles at both ends of the part by clicking on 'Sketch' and drawing two circles. Click on 'Boss Extrude' to extrude the desired length from the plane of the base piece. Click on the sketch of the smaller circle to cut into the extrude by clicking 'Cut Extrude' to make room for the shaft. To strengthen this joint, click on 'Fillet' to smoothen the sharp joints.
         NOTE: The dimensions of the circles depend on the size of the shaft to be used during mounting the flipper on top of the water flume. In our case, the diameter of the smaller circle is 0.5 inches and the bigger circle is 1 inches. The base end will be sitting outside the flipper skin geometry, so the size of the knuckles does not fall under the constraints of the skin.
   2. Middle Piece
      1. Make the length of this piece proportional to the distance between the wrist joint and the knuckle joint of a Sea lion. Do this by clicking on 'Sketch' and sketching the desired shape (as shown in Figure 4b) on a plane. Once the geometry is designed, click on 'Extrude' to get the basic three-dimensional shape of the middle piece. Input the extruded length as 0.1650 inches.
         NOTE: The desired shape of the middle piece in our experiment is a trapezoid with a height of 2.25 inches and the length of the two bases as 1.625 and 0.850 inches respectively.
      2. Add knuckles on both ends. Do this as described in step 2.2.1.2. The diameter of the extruded cut is 0.125 inches. Connect the knuckles on the base end to the tip end of the base piece with an axel to form a hinge representing the wrist joint.
         NOTE: The knuckles need to fit inside the volume of the foreflipper, so design accordingly.
      3. Add a tower approximately 1 cm in height to the tip end of the piece on both sides.
         1. To add a tower, click on 'Sketch' and sketch a rectangle on the base of the model. Extrude the sketch by selecting the sketch and clicking on 'Boss Extrude'. The thickness of the tower in this particular case is 0.165 inches.
         2. Click on 'Fillet' and select the model and one edge of the extruded tower. This strengthens the sharp joint where the tower and the base of the middle piece are connected. It is okay if the tower protrudes from the geometry of the skin. The tower should be thick enough to withstand the forces generated during a flipper clap. See Figure 4 for reference.
   3. Tip Piece
      1. Make the length of this piece proportional to the distance between the knuckle joint and the tip of the longest finger bone of a Sea lion. Do this by clicking on 'Sketch' and sketching a desired shape on a plane. Once the geometry is designed, click on extrude to get the basic three-dimensional shape of the tip piece.
      2. Add knuckles on both ends. Do this as described in step 2.2.1.2. The diameter of the extruded cut should be equal to the diameter of the axle, which in this experiment is 0.125 inches. The knuckles on the base end will be connected to the tip end of the middle piece with an axle to form a hinge representing the knuckle joint. The geometry of these knuckles needs to fit inside the geometry of the foreflipper skin, so design accordingly.
      3. Add a tower approximately 1 cm in height to the base end of the piece on both sides. Do this described in step 2.2.2.3. The thickness of the tower in this particular case is 0.165 inches. It is okay if the tower protrudes from the geometry of the skin. The tower should be thick enough to withstand the forces generated during a flipper clap. See Figure 5 for reference.

3. Creating a Flipper

1. 3D print the skeleton (base, middle and tip pieces) of the flipper. Convert the '.SLDRPT' file from CAD to '.STL' and import it into the printer's proprietary software and click 'Print'.
   NOTE: The printing instructions are different for each printer.
   1. Reinforce the knuckles of the middle and tip piece with an adhesive (epoxy) and carbon threads. To do this, cut carbon threads of length 0.750 inches. Apply adhesive to the 3D printed bone structures and lay the threads over the knuckles. It is not necessary to reinforce the large knuckles on the base piece (Figure 5a).
   2. Drill holes at the bottom of each tower the diameter of the Kevlar string (strings that will be used to actuate the joints).
   3. Assemble all bone pieces together from base to tip using axles. Do this by placing all the components on a flat table as shown in Figure 4. To connect the base and middle piece, align the knuckles of the parts and insert the axle. Use the same technique to connect the middle and the tip piece together. Use an adhesive on each end of each axle to ensure the axle does not move laterally (Figure 5b).
   4. Cut plastic tubes to the following length. Cut four tubes the length of the base bone piece (L₁ = 8 cm) and two tubes the length of the middle piece (L₂ = 6 cm).
   5. Cut 4 pieces of Kevlar string, each 3 feet in length.
   6. Slide one string through an L₁ tube and then an L₂ tube. Slide another string through an L₁ tube. Repeat the process with the remaining tubes and strings.
   7. Place the tubes on top of the bone structures and use a clear tape to hold them in position temporarily. Using an adhesive, stick the tubes onto the bone structure and then remove the tapes.
      NOTE: There is no specific position in which the tubes have to be placed, the critical aspect is to just stick them on the surface of the structure. Use Figure 5c as a guideline.
   8. Thread the Kevlar string from L₁ tube and L₂ tube through the holes drilled onto the tip and middle pieces as described in step 3.1.2. Make a small but secure knot once the string is through the hole (Figure 5d).
2. Adding the skin of the flipper to create a final flipper.
   1. Measure 200 mL of silicon and silicon medium in two different containers.
   2. Pour both these liquids into a steel bowl. Add paint thinner (not to exceed 10% of weight of the total mixture) to the mixture for easy pouring and mixing.
   3. Use a stand mixer to mix the mixture thoroughly for 3 - 4 min. Color can be added at this step to achieve the desired visual effects. If a stand mixer is not available, use a whisk to mix it, taking care to scrape the sides and bottom of the container.
   4. Insert a rod into the knuckles of the base part and align it with the knuckles of the flipper mold. When the pegs fit into the cavities of the mold, the bone structure is aligned perfectly in the flipper mold. While holding down on the two parts of mold, secure the parts by using a clamp for added compression (this step is critical so that the silicon mixture does not leak from the gap between the two parts).
   5. Once the mixture is mixed, carefully pour it in the mold till the topmost knuckles of the bone structure. Oozing of liquid from the bottom hole in the mold is a sign of the mixture getting uniformly distributed. At the onset of this, plug the hole to avoid further flow of the liquid. Leave the liquid to cure for four hours before removing the flipper robot from the mold (see Figure 6).

4. Mounting

1. To mount the silicon foreflipper on the water flume (Figure 7), create a mounting structure. A CAD representation of the finished assembly is shown. (Figure 8).
   1. Design a plate with a carefully extruded cut using CAD software. Click on 'Sketch' and draw a rectangle of dimensions 14 x 19 inches (the height does not matter as the laser cutter uses a .dwg file). Use a rectangular sheet of steel as the base to manufacture this plate. Upload a two-dimensional drawing from the CAD software on a computer attached to a steel laser cutter to attain the desired cuts.
      NOTE: This plate houses the motor and the cut in it allows for the pulley system to work. The width of the plate is equal to the width of the water flume, thus making it easier to slide the plate over the flume. This type of placement helps in easy removal of the mounting assembly to replace parts or the foreflipper model.
   2. Fix the foreflipper and the pulley onto a shaft, which slides into a triangular truss.
      NOTE: A three-pulley system is implemented to transfer the torque/power from the motor to the rod.
   3. Use bearings on either side to help the rod to rotate smoothly. To restrict the movement of rod in the lateral direction, place shaft collars on each end of the shaft.
2. Set the motion of the flipper by selecting the jogging function on the driver. Pressing the 'Up' button rotates the flipper clockwise and the 'Down' button rotates the flipper anticlockwise. The driver allows for change the revolutions per minute of the motor shaft according to the instructions in the manual²⁰.
3. Insert the right-angled dye port in the water and increase the pressure on the dye system. Adjust the speed of the dye to the freestream velocity of the water so the dye appears as a single smooth filament. Rotate the flipper so that the dye interacts and gets trapped with the resulting vortices generated.

Results

The process described above yields a robotic model of a California sea lion foreflipper. The model can be used in two different ways. One is by actuating the flipper only at the root (Figure 6a). In this case, the driving motor sets the rotational rate of the first joint, but the resulting motion of the flipper is determined by the fluid-structure interaction between the flexible flipper and the surrounding water. Additionally, we can create robotic flipp...

Discussion

The robotic flipper apparatus will allow us to understand the hydrodynamics of the swimming California sea lion. This includes the basic thrust producing stroke (the 'clap'), as well as non-physical variations that animal studies cannot investigate. The robotic flipper has been designed for experimental versatility, thus, step 3—where the flipper itself is made—is critical in obtaining the desired results. While this apparatus is, clearly, just a model of the living system, in situ studies of...

Materials

Name	Company	Catalog Number	Comments
Dragon Skin 20	Smooth-on
Dragon Skin 20 medium	Smooth-on
Object24	Stratasys		3D printer
Stand Mixer	Hamilton
PKS-PRO-E-10 System	Anaheim Automation	PKS-PRO-E-10-A-LP22	Controller and Servo Motor
Artec Eva	Artec 3D		3D light scanner with resolution of 0.1 mm
Artec Spider	Artec 3D		3D light scanner with resolution of 0.5 mm
Steel plate	Mcmaster
Carbon Tow	Fibreglast	2393-A
Hardened Precision 440C Stainless Steel Shaft	Mcmaster	6253K49
Tygon PVC Clear Tubing	Mcmaster	6546T23
Kevlar Thread	Mcmaster