JoVE Logo

Sign In

The prisoner's dilemma is a fundamental example in game theory. It shows how two rational individuals might not cooperate, even when it's in their best interest to do so. It also demonstrates the concept of Nash equilibrium, where each player's choice is the best response to the other's decision.

Imagine two business rivals, Firm A and Firm B, that are accused of price-fixing. They are questioned separately and have two options: to confess (betray the other) or to deny (cooperate). The outcomes depend on their decisions:

  1. If both firms deny involvement, they receive a minimal penalty, such as a small fine. The best collective outcome is when neither firm provides evidence against the other.
  2. If Firm A confesses while Firm B denies, Firm A is rewarded with no penalty, while Firm B faces a severe penalty, like a hefty fine or further legal action. The reverse happens if Firm B confesses and Firm A denies.
  3. If both firms confess, they receive moderate fines that are worse than if both had denied, but better than the severe punishment one would face alone.

The Nash equilibrium in this scenario occurs when both firms choose to confess. Even though denying would be better for both, each has the fear of cooperating with the other firm confessing. This leads them both to act defensively, resulting in each firm suffering a less favorable outcome than if they had both cooperated. This example illustrates how the structure of incentives can lead rational players to make decisions that do not maximize their joint benefit. The Prisoner's Dilemma game highlights the challenges of cooperation when trust and communication are absent.

From Chapter 15:

article

Now Playing

15.8 : Prisoner's Dilemma I

Game Theory

2 Views

article

15.1 : Introduction to Game Theory

Game Theory

11 Views

article

15.2 : Cooperative vs. Non-Cooperative Games

Game Theory

10 Views

article

15.3 : Player and Strategies

Game Theory

6 Views

article

15.4 : Zero-Sum and Non-Zero-Sum Game

Game Theory

13 Views

article

15.5 : Payoffs

Game Theory

3 Views

article

15.6 : Dominant and Dominated Strategies

Game Theory

5 Views

article

15.7 : Equilibrium in Dominant Strategies

Game Theory

6 Views

article

15.9 : Prisoner's Dilemma II

Game Theory

3 Views

article

15.10 : Nash Equilibrium in One-Period Games

Game Theory

3 Views

article

15.11 : Multiple Equilibria

Game Theory

3 Views

article

15.12 : Mixed Strategies

Game Theory

6 Views

article

15.13 : The Maximin Strategy I

Game Theory

6 Views

article

15.14 : The Maximin Strategy II

Game Theory

14 Views

article

15.15 : Finitely Repeated Games

Game Theory

9 Views

See More

JoVE Logo

Privacy

Terms of Use

Policies

Research

Education

ABOUT JoVE

Copyright © 2025 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved