Sign In

Categories and Inductive Inferences

Overview

Source: Laboratories of Nicholaus Noles and Judith Danovitch—University of Louisville

It might be possible for the human brain to keep track of each individual person, place, or thing encountered, but that would be a very inefficient use of time and cognitive resources. Instead, humans develop categories. Categories are mental representations of real things that can be used for a variety of purposes. For example, individuals can use the perceptual features of animals to place them into a given category. So, upon seeing a furry, four-legged, tail-wagging, barking animal, a person can determine that it is a dog. This is one of many examples where people use perceptual similarity to fit new experiences into their existing mental representations.

However, category membership is much more than skin deep, especially for representations of animals. Frank Keil demonstrated this by using a simple, yet powerful technique that focused on the differences between natural kinds and artifacts. Natural kinds include animals and other living things, while artifacts consist largely of nonliving things, such as tables or gold bricks. In his study, Keil told children stories about natural kinds and artifacts that underwent transformations causing them to cross categorical boundaries. For example, he described a step-by-step process by which a raccoon was transformed into a creature that resembled a skunk in every way. At the end of the story, the raccoon was black with a white stripe, and it had implanted glands that made it smell like a skunk, too. He asked the children to determine whether the resulting animal was a raccoon or a skunk. He used a similar method to describe the transformation of a tire-an artifact-into a shoe. Children's responses revealed interesting developmental changes into how people think about artifacts and natural kinds.

This video demonstrates Frank Keil's transformation study.1

Procedure

Recruit healthy 5-, 7-, and 9-year-old children with normal hearing and vision and no history of developmental disorders. For the purposes of this demonstration, only one child is tested. Larger sample sizes (as in Frank Keil's transformation study1) are recommended when conducting any experiments.

1. Data collection

  1. Gather the necessary materials.
    1. Design eight vignettes describing the transformation of animals from one kind to another via surgery.

    Log in or to access full content. Learn more about your institution’s access to JoVE content here

    Results

    In order to have enough power to see significant results, researchers would have to test at least 18 children in each age group. Typically, when asked about artifacts, children in all three age groups conclude that what is seen confirms the categorical placement. If a tire is transformed into a rubber shoe, then it is a shoe and not a tire. In contrast, children presented with natural kinds reveal a developmental trend. Five-year-olds are either indecisive or see an animal's posttransform

    Log in or to access full content. Learn more about your institution’s access to JoVE content here

    Application and Summary

    Frank Keil's work demonstrates that internal characteristics count. Children treat category membership as springing from internal characteristics that cause animals' appearances and behaviors, and children continue to have the intuition that animals belong to their category, even when appearances and behaviors change. Generally, this finding supports other work demonstrating that children use categorical information and not other cues, such as appearance, to guide their inferences about animals. For example, indi

    Log in or to access full content. Learn more about your institution’s access to JoVE content here

    References
    1. Keil, F.C. Concepts, Kinds, and Cognitive Development. MIT Press: Cambridge, MA (1989).
    Tags
    CategoriesInductive InferencesCognitive ResourcesObjectsPeopleLocationsMental RepresentationFeaturesSeedsHidden FeatureObserved FeatureAnimalDogEducated GuessesUnfamiliar Category MembersPet DogTail wagging DogFrank KeilStimuli DesignTransformational StudyCategorization DataPsychologistsChildren s Inferences

    Skip to...

    0:00

    Overview

    1:50

    Experimental Design

    4:23

    Running the Experiment

    6:21

    Representative Results

    7:31

    Applications

    9:33

    Summary

    Videos from this collection:

    article

    Now Playing

    Categories and Inductive Inferences

    Developmental Psychology

    5.2K Views

    article

    Habituation: Studying Infants Before They Can Talk

    Developmental Psychology

    53.1K Views

    article

    Using Your Head: Measuring Infants' Rational Imitation of Actions

    Developmental Psychology

    10.1K Views

    article

    The Rouge Test: Searching for a Sense of Self

    Developmental Psychology

    53.8K Views

    article

    Numerical Cognition: More or Less

    Developmental Psychology

    14.9K Views

    article

    Mutual Exclusivity: How Children Learn the Meanings of Words

    Developmental Psychology

    32.6K Views

    article

    How Children Solve Problems Using Causal Reasoning

    Developmental Psychology

    13.0K Views

    article

    Metacognitive Development: How Children Estimate Their Memory

    Developmental Psychology

    10.4K Views

    article

    Executive Function and the Dimensional Change Card Sort Task

    Developmental Psychology

    14.8K Views

    article

    The Costs and Benefits of Natural Pedagogy

    Developmental Psychology

    5.1K Views

    article

    Piaget's Conservation Task and the Influence of Task Demands

    Developmental Psychology

    59.6K Views

    article

    Children's Reliance on Artist Intentions When Identifying Pictures

    Developmental Psychology

    5.6K Views

    article

    Measuring Children's Trust in Testimony

    Developmental Psychology

    6.3K Views

    article

    Are You Smart or Hardworking? How Praise Influences Children's Motivation

    Developmental Psychology

    14.2K Views

    article

    Memory Development: Demonstrating How Repeated Questioning Leads to False Memories

    Developmental Psychology

    10.7K Views

    JoVE Logo

    Privacy

    Terms of Use

    Policies

    Research

    Education

    ABOUT JoVE

    Copyright © 2025 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved