Published: November 1st, 2018
Here, we present an experimental protocol that can be employed to determine the binding affinities and mode of interaction of label-free phospholipid-binding protein annexin A2 with immobilized solid-supported bilayers (SLB) by simultaneously measuring the mass uptake and the viscoelastic properties of the protein annexin A2.
The dissipative quartz crystal microbalance technique is a simple and label-free approach to measure simultaneously the mass uptake and viscoelastic properties of the absorbed/immobilized mass on sensor surfaces, allowing the measurements of the interaction of proteins with solid-supported surfaces, such as lipid bilayers, in real-time and with a high sensitivity. Annexins are a highly conserved group of phospholipid-binding proteins that interact reversibly with the negatively charged headgroups via the coordination of calcium ions. Here, we describe a protocol that was employed to quantitatively analyze the binding of annexin A2 (AnxA2) to planar lipid bilayers prepared on the surface of a quartz sensor. This protocol is optimized to obtain robust and reproducible data and includes a detailed step-by-step description. The method can be applied to other membrane-binding proteins and bilayer compositions.
Cellular membranes are highly dynamic and complex structures. The compound mixture of membrane lipids, together with peripherally and/or integrally associated membrane proteins, assemble to form microdomains. The coordinated tempo-spatial organization of these membrane microdomains is involved in key physiological processes1. Membrane microdomain dynamics are driven by the interplay of membrane lipids, as well as by the ability of peripheral membrane proteins to recognize and interact with lipids enriched in the microdomains. The recruitment of the proteins to the specific lipids is often achieved via lipid-recognition modules, such as the pleckstrin homology (PH) or the C2 domains2,3. Biophysical analytical methods using model membranes are key to understanding the fundamental principles governing these processes at the molecular level.
Annexins, a large multigene-family, are well-known for their ability to bind to negatively charged membrane lipids, predominantly phosphatidylserine (PS), in a Ca2+-controlled manner2. The second hallmark of the annexin family is the presence of a conserved structural segment, the annexin repeat, that is present four or eight times and harbors the Ca2+- and phospholipid-binding sites4. The Ca2+-dependent lipid interaction places the annexins in a perfect position to sense and convey Ca2+-mediated signaling to target membranes. Consistently, annexins are able to induce the formation of microdomains enriched in cholesterol, phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate (PI(4,5)P2), and PS, both in cellular and/or artificial membrane systems5. This protocol describes an approach to analyze the annexin-membrane interaction using a Quartz Crystal Microbalance Dissipation (QCM-D)6,7,8.
The basic component in this microbalance is an oscillating crystal that serves as the sensor surface. The adsorption and/or binding of molecules to the sensor surface decreases the resonance frequency (f) proportional to the increase in mass. If the surface is evenly coated with a film, the binding of additional substances may interfere with the structural integrity of this layer, and such changes in viscoelasticity (the energy dissipation factor D) can be additionally monitored. This is a widespread technique to study the interaction of proteins with lipid bilayers. In this approach, lipid vesicles are absorbed onto the appropriately coated sensor surface. Lipid bilayer formation is favorable on silica-based materials9,10, as vesicles often do not rupture on other hydrophilic surfaces, such as gold11 oxidized after UV-ozone exposure, TiO212, or Al2O313. The rupture of the coalescing vesicles releases the aqueous phase, leading to characteristic changes in mass and dissipation. The generation of solid-supported bilayers (SLB) by vesicle fusion is simple and robust and can be used to generate complex models that mimic cellular membranes.
Dissipative quartz crystal microbalance is a label-free and sensitive technique. A major advantage is the possibility to coat any material that generates a sufficiently thin film onto the surface, thus providing a broad range of applications in diverse research areas. The protein-membrane interaction is observed in real-time, and the results can be analyzed directly. The same sensor surface can be used in subsequent measurements (after performing a minimal cleaning as described in this protocol), thus allowing for accurate internal controls and a comparability between analytes.
NOTE: Buffers should be filtered using a 0.22-µm filter and degassed by a vacuum for 1 h.
1. Lipid Vesicle Preparation
2. Handling the Quartz Sensors
NOTE: Always handle the quartz sensors with a tweezer.
3. Microbalance Operation
NOTE: A microbalance system with four temperature-controlled flow chambers in a parallel configuration, connected to a peristaltic pump and set to a flow rate of 80 µL/min, was used. In the open flow mode, the buffer was pumped from the feeder reservoir into the receiving tank. In the loop mode, the receiving tank was connected with the feeder reservoir to generate a closed loop. The temperature was set to 20 °C.
4. Microbalance Cleaning
NOTE: Perform a minimal cleaning procedure after each measurement.
The decrease in the resonant frequency (Δf) correlates in a linear manner with the adsorbed mass (Δm), as defined by the Sauerbrey equation.17
Here, f is the resonant frequency, Cf is a constant that depends on the geometrical and physical characteristics of the given quartz and the resonant frequency, and A is the sensor surface area.
In most applications, the adsorbed layer is not completely rigid but viscoelastic. The resulting dampening of the quartz sensor oscillation is referred to as dissipation (D). The monitored dissipation changes (ΔD) correlate with the viscoelastic properties of the bound mass18 and are defined as follows8.
Here, Edissipated is the energy lost during one oscillation period, and Estored is the total energy of the freely oscillating sensor.
To analyze and quantify the binding parameters, frequency isotherms are derived by plotting the equilibrium frequency shifts (ΔΔfe) against the protein concentrations. ΔΔfe is defined as
Here, Δft1 represents the beginning of the protein adsorption and Δft2 the equilibrium state. Nonlinear curve fitting can be performed by using a Hill expansion of the Langmuir equation as follows6,8.
Here, ΔΔfmax is the ΔΔfe of the protein concentration resulting in maximum (saturating) binding, Kd is the apparent dissociation constant for the protein/membrane complex, and n is the Hill coefficient.
The Hill coefficient (n) describes the cooperativity of binding. For n = 1, the Hill adsorption model is a simple Langmuir isotherm (the equal binding sites and all molecules bind independently of each other to the lipid bilayer). If n ≠ 1, a bound ligand changes the membrane binding affinity for other ligands, either increasing (n > 1, positive cooperativity) or decreasing (n < 1, negative cooperativity) the affinity.
Figure 1 shows a schematic of the experimental workflow used in our laboratory to measure the shifts in resonance and frequency during Ca2+-dependent binding and the release of AnxA2 to the lipid bilayer in the liquid phase. An exemplary recording is shown in Figure 2. Figure 2A shows the recording of the frequency curve and Figure 2B shows the dissipation shifts. The prominent drop in frequency upon the addition of the liposomes (Figure 2A [step 1]) indicates their adsorption. Because the buffer-filled vesicles are not rigid, but viscoelastic, the dissipation increases (Figure 2B [step 1]). Subsequently, the coalescing vesicles rupture. The concomitant release of the buffer inside the vesicles decreases the adsorbed mass until a stable plateau is reached (Figure 2A [step 2]). Of note, the addition of vesicles results in a high dissipation shift, while the shift in response to the bilayer is much smaller due to the rigid homogenous nature of the SLB (Figure 2B [step 2]). Step 3 in Figure 2A and 2B records the binding of AnxA2 to the lipids, which adds mass, as seen by the clear frequency shift, but does not interfere with the bilayer structure, as indicated by the only small change in dissipation. When Ca2+ is removed by the chelating agent EGTA (Figure 1 and Figure 2 [step 4]), AnxA2 dissociates from the lipid film. The frequency, as well as the dissipation recordings, shift to the levels seen with the bilayer only (compare steps 2 and 4 in Figure 2A and 2B), indicating that AnxA2 binding is totally dependent on Ca2+ and that the lipid film remains intact.
AnxA2, as do most of the annexins, depends on negatively charged lipids such as PS. This is clearly seen when POPS is absent in the lipid bilayer (Figure 3). Figure 3A shows the recording of the frequency curve and Figure 3B shows the dissipation shifts. Note that the frequency shifts to a stable baseline at -25 Hz, yet the dissipation is not altered (Figure 3B [step 2]), indicative of a proper bilayer formation. However, no changes in frequency (Figure 3A) or dissipation (Figure 3B) are observed after the addition of AnxA2 in the presence of Ca2+ (Figure 3A and 3B [step 3]) or EGTA (Figure 3A and 3B [step 4]), as AnxA2 cannot interact with the lipid film.
Figure 1: Graphical model of the experimental workflow. This workflow illustrates the vesicle absorption to the hydrophilic sensor surface (step 1), the vesicle fusion/rupture leading to the SLB formation (step 2), and the Ca2+-dependent adsorption (step 3) and EGTA-dependent desorption of AnxA2 (step 4). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Exemplary recording. These panels show (A) the time-dependent monitoring of the 7th overtone resonance frequency and (B) the dissipation shifts of the quartz sensors during measurement. The application of the liposomes causes a rapid drop in the frequency baseline, whereas the dissipation baseline increases (step 1). The stabilization of the baselines indicates the formation of the bilayer (step 2). The AnxA2 (200 nM) adsorption (in the presence of Ca2+) onto the POPS-containing lipid bilayer adds mass without significantly changing the dissipation, indicating that the lipid film is not perturbed (step 3). The recovery of the frequency baseline upon Ca2+ chelation with EGTA indicates the total desorption of the protein (step 4). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Negative control experiment, demonstrating that AnxA2 does not bind to SLBs in the absence of POPS. These panels show the addition of liposomes and the SLB formation (steps 1 and 2). No changes in (A) frequency or (B) dissipation are apparent after the addition of AnxA2 (step 3; 200 nM, in the presence of Ca2+) or EGTA (step 4). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
|ΔΔF/Hz after formation of SLBs
|ΔΔD*10-6 after formation of SLB
(80 : 20)
|26.3 ± 0.2
|0.26 ± 0.03
(95 : 5)
|26.5 ± 0.5
|0.31 ± 0.02
(60 : 20 : 20)
|29.2 ± 0.2
|0.45 ± 0.09
(60 : 17 : 3 : 20)
|29.6 ± 0.6
|0.43 ± 0.10
(37 : 20 : 20 : 3 : 20)
|29.4 ± 0.4
|0.39 ± 0.14
Table 1: Lipid composition and formation data of the SLB7.
To answer questions concerning the structure-function relationship of cellular membranes both in a quantitative and qualitative manner, cell biology profits immensely from the use of biophysical approaches based on well-established and widely used techniques, including atomic force microscopy (AFM), surface plasmon resonance (SPR), and the QCM-D technique employed here. We showed in previous studies that annexin proteins bind in a Ca2+-dependent manner to the immobilized membrane with high affinity. We use frequency and dissipation shifts of the 7th overtone (Δf7) because this represents the best compromise of detection sensitivity and oscillation stability.
This technique also permits a quantitative description of the membrane-protein interaction. AnxA2 binding to the membrane is characterized by positive cooperativity that is mediated by the conserved annexin core domain and depends on the presence of cholesterol. The quantitative data obtained for AnxA2 and AnxA8 are reported in detail elsewhere6,8.
There are many critical steps in this protocol. Use the liposomes immediately; otherwise, small vesicles might fuse into bigger vesicles with less surface tension, leading to the inhibition of the lipid bilayer formation. Maintain a constant temperature during the measurements. Each small deviation in temperature results in a not negligible frequency and dissipation shift. Avoid air bubbles; otherwise, the system is unstable and will not establish a baseline.
The Sauerbrey equation allows the direct conversion of the observed frequency changes into changes in mass and is, therefore, widely used. However, the assumption of a linear correlation between the change in resonance frequency and the added mass only holds true for components forming a rigid and uniform film on the sensor surface. The Sauerbrey equation cannot be used for viscoelastic adsorbents such as water-rich protein films, lipid layers with incorporated water, or even adsorbed cells. Here, more complex mathematical models are required. Therefore, it is extremely important to simultaneously monitor the changes in frequency and dissipation. To detect structural changes during the measurement, ΔD versus Δf ratios can be plotted, with a straight line indicating no conformational changes.
A major advantage of this technique is the possibility to use a very broad range of materials as substrates. Moreover, it is a reliable and direct method to study a broad range of macromolecular interactions, as the proper formation of the surface-coating films (such as SLB), as well as further protein-lipid interactions, can be monitored online.
This protocol can be applied to other membrane-interacting proteins, for example, BAR domain proteins19, the ERM (ezrin, radixin, and moesin) protein family that has an important role in membrane-cytoskeleton linkage20,21,22, or proteins containing C2 or PH domains. Moreover, a wide range of applications of this technique to study biological materials has been successfully published, thus establishing QCM as a well-suited experimental platform to study the interactions of more complex macromolecular assemblies or even cells23,24.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft under grants SFB 858/B04, EXC 1003, SFB 1348/A04, and SFB 1348/A11.
|Qsense E4 Analyzer
|Pump IPC 4
|QSX 303 SiO2 Silicon dioxide 50nm
|PC Membranes 0.05μm
|Avanti polar lipids
|Version 8 and 9
Copyright © 2024 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved