* These authors contributed equally
Detailed instructions are provided to build an open-source, modular fluorimeter that is compatible with many low-cost heaters to perform real-time, quantitative isothermal nucleic acid amplification.
Traditional methods to detect and quantify nucleic acids rely on polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and require the use of expensive thermocyclers with integrated fluorescence detection of amplicons. Isothermal nucleic acid amplification technologies eliminate the need for thermal cycling; however, fluorescence-based detection of products is still required for real-time, quantitative results. Several portable isothermal heaters with integrated fluorescence detection are now commercially available; however, the cost of these devices remains a significant barrier to widespread adoption in resource-limited settings. Described here is a protocol for the design and assembly of a modular, low-cost fluorimeter constructed from off-the-shelf components. Enclosed in a compact 3D printed housing, the fluorimeter is designed to be placed atop a commercially available heat block holding a PCR tube. The fluorimeter described here was optimized to detect fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) dye, but the system can be modified for use with dyes commonly used as reporters in real-time nucleic acid amplification reactions. Clinical applicability of the system is demonstrated by performing real-time nucleic acid detection with two isothermal amplification technologies: recombinase polymerase amplification (RPA) for detection of positive control DNA provided in a commercial kit and reverse transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification (RT-LAMP) for detection of clinically meaningful levels of SARS-CoV-2 RNA.
Isothermal amplification technologies are widely used for detection of nucleic acids. Compared to traditional PCR approaches that require thermocycling, isothermal amplification allows nucleic acid amplification to occur at a single temperature, thus enabling faster time-to-results and better tolerance of inhibitors1,2. Another key benefit of isothermal amplification is the reduced instrumentation complexity. Most isothermal amplification reactions only require a heat block and a detection modality-either real-time detection via fluorescence monitoring or endpoint detection, for example by lateral flow or gel electrophoresis3,4. Real-time fluorescence detection is accomplished through the detection of fluorescence produced by intercalating dyes that activate in the presence of double-stranded DNA or quenched fluorescent probes that activate in the presence of specific double-stranded DNA sequences.
While commercially available benchtop isothermal fluorimeters exist, many lack customization for assay implementation. For example, many devices require specific or company-provided consumables, recommend preferred vendors, or utilize proprietary software to obtain advertised results. Most of these systems cost over $5,000 USD, representing a significant barrier for widespread use in resource-limited settings. In addition, users in low-resource settings face challenges to maintain equipment designed for high-resource settings due to harsh environmental conditions, weak supply chains for spare parts, and specialized tools required for maintenance and repair5. To meet this need, described here is the design and assembly of a modular and low-cost fluorimeter constructed from off-the-shelf components enclosed in a compact 3D printed housing (Figures 1A-C) with two optional configurations. The first configuration of this device uses commercially available glass filters and a dichroic mirror to block excess background light and has a total cost of assembly of $830 USD. While these filters are commonly used in fluorescence-based imaging systems, replacing expensive high-grade optical filter foils has previously been shown to allow for nucleic acid detection6. The second configuration of the fluorimeter incorporates these inexpensive filters and replaces the dichroic mirrors with φ½" beam splitters, reducing the overall cost of the system from $830 to $450 USD.
Representative images of the assembly are shown for the first configuration in Figure 1 and Figure 2, but analogous images for the second configuration can be found in Supplemental File 6. To avoid the need for specialized optical alignment, the optical system has designated areas to place each optical component and can be made with a relatively low-end 3D printer, allowing for widespread use of the design. The only differences in construction and assembly for the two configurations are the files used for 3D printing and the optical components placed into the enclosure. The external dimensions of the 3D printed enclosure for both systems are the same. A cost comparison of the two systems is shown in Table 1.
As shown in Figure 1A, to maintain a small form factor, the fluorimeter consists of Φ½" (~12.5 mm) optics, coupled with compact illumination and detection that are placed to measure signal through the top of the PCR tube. The system in Figure 1 is designed to detect dyes with peak excitation and emission wavelengths near 490 nm and 525 nm, respectively, including FITC and closely related dyes such as SYBR and SYTO-9, which are commonly used as reporters in real-time nucleic acid amplification reactions7,8. The excitation source, optical filters, and detector can readily be substituted for components compatible with different fluorescent dyes as desired. Nucleic acid amplification reactions are typically performed in PCR tubes, and the fluorimeter is designed to be placed atop any commercially available heat block that holds PCR tubes (Figure 1D) allowing for real time monitoring of isothermal reactions. Appropriate heat blocks are available in most biomedical laboratories and can be purchased for less than $500 USD.
The use of single-board computers to provide a low-cost, point of care alternative for controlling imaging technologies has been previously demonstrated9. Building off that work, in this protocol a single-board computer-powered graphical user interface (Figure 1D) is used to facilitate real-time data logging and display of results at the point of care, eliminating the need for a laptop computer to process or visualize data. Fluorescence measurements were transferred through I2C protocol from the light sensors to a microcontroller, and then made available to the single-board computer through serial communication. Electrical connections for illumination and data transfer were provided through simplified wiring and soldering on miniaturized breadboards, negating the need for specialized printed circuit boards (PCBs). The software required to run the fluorimeter is available through open-source software frameworks and the code required to run the device is provided in the supplemental coding files. The complete fluorimeter can be assembled for between $450 to $830 USD, and results show that it provides accurate and reliable fluorescence measurements to monitor real-time isothermal amplification of nucleic acids.
1. Preparation steps: 3D printing and soldering
NOTE: The optical system described in this protocol is designed for a standard dry block heater.
2. Optical assembly
3. Electronics and touchscreen assembly
4. Software installation
5. Recording real-time fluorescence data
Once assembled, fluorimeter performance can be validated by measuring fluorescence from a dilution series of FITC dye. In Figure 3A, measurements of FITC dye at concentrations of 0, 20, 40, 60, and 80 pg/µL prepared in 1x PBS on both channels of the first configuration of the fluorimeter are shown. Each sample was measured three times with an LED exposure of 1.5 s at 20 s intervals. Both channels of the fluorimeter show a linear response across the desired range.
Clinical applicability of the fluorimeter was further demonstrated by using the system together with a commercially available dry heat block to perform amplification with two isothermal amplification technologies: RPA and RT-LAMP.
Figure 3B demonstrates the baseline-subtracted time course of fluorescence measured during 39 °C amplification of 50 µL of real-time RPA positive and negative control reactions for kit positive control DNA provided in a standard commercial kit and prepared per manufacturer's instructions. RPA reactions, which produce a relatively low level of fluorescence, were measured using the first configuration of the fluorimeter that achieves better suppression of excitation light.
Figure 3C demonstrates the time course measurement of a custom RT-LAMP assay at 65 °C utilizing the N2, E1, and As1e primer sets described by Zhang et al10, and Rabe and Cepko11. RT-LAMP reactions produce a greater amount of fluorescence and were measured using the second, lower-cost fluorimeter configuration. Oligonucleotides were purchased and resuspended in 2x TE buffer at a 1 mM concentration. Forward inner primer (FIP) and backward inner primer (BIP) oligos were ordered with high performance liquid chromatography purification. Each primer set (N2, E1, and As1e) was combined to make 1000 µL of a 25x mix as follows: 40 µL of FIP, 40 µL of BIP, 5 µL of F3, 5 µL of B3, 10 µL of LF, 10 µL of LB, and 890 µL of 1x TE buffer. To assemble each RT-LAMP reaction, 1 µL of each primer set was added to 0.5 µL of 50x fluorescent dye and 12.5 µL of 2x master mix and the reaction volume was brought up to 20 µL with nuclease-free water per manufacturer's instructions. The SARS-CoV-2 RNA Control was serially diluted in nuclease-free water to concentrations of 10, 100, or 1,000 copies per µL, and 5 µL were added for a total reaction volume of 25 µL. The no target control (NTC) used in all experiments was nuclease-free water. RT-LAMP reactions were overlayed with 25 µL of molecular biology-grade mineral oil.
RPA and RT-LAMP reactions were assembled in two wells of a 0.2 mL low-profile 8-tube PCR strip and capped with ultraclear flat caps. Each RPA and RT-LAMP reaction was run in triplicate. In all tests, the mini-fluorimeter successfully quantified the temporal increase of fluorescence levels associated with DNA amplification.
Figure 1: Optical housing and assembled miniature fluorimeter atop heat block. (A) Diagram of optical housing showing optical components placed in one detection channel. (B) Diagram of the first configuration of the miniature fluorimeter following assembly. (C) Photograph of the optical housing with optical components placed in one detection channel. (D) Photograph of assembled miniature fluorimeter placed on top of a commercially available heat block. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Assembly and electrical control diagram of the miniature fluorimeter. A-J) Step-by-step placement of the optical components in the 3D printed optical housing for the first system configuration. (K) Electrical diagram of the miniature fluorimeter for both configurations. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Representative measurements obtained with the miniature fluorimeter. (A) Measured fluorescence vs. FITC dye concentration in both channels shows linear response across the desired dynamic range. (B) Real-time fluorescence vs time for isothermal amplification of positive and negative controls of a commercially available kit. Amplification occurs as expected for the positive control. (C) Real-time fluorescence vs time for isothermal amplification of 50, 500, and 5000 copies of SARS-CoV-2 RNA and an NTC sample from a custom RT-LAMP assay. Amplification occurs as expected near the limit of detection of the assay. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
System 1 | System 2 | |||
Item | Quantity | Total Price (USD) | Quantity | Total Price (USD) |
Optical Components | ||||
Lenses | 6 | 158.14 | 6 | 158.14 |
Mirrors | 2 | 244.56 | 2 | 60 |
Optical Filters | 4 | 200 | 6 | 5 |
Subtotal | 602.7 | Subtotal | 223.14 | |
Illumination and Detection | ||||
LEDs | 2 | 72.62 | 2 | 72.62 |
LED Driver | 1 | 11.49 | 1 | 11.49 |
Photodiode | 2 | 50 | 2 | 50 |
Subtotal | 134.11 | Subtotal | 134.11 | |
Electronics and Display | ||||
Arduino Nano | 1 | 20.7 | 1 | 20.7 |
Raspberry Pi | 1 | 35 | 1 | 35 |
LCD Screen | 1 | 25 | 1 | 25 |
Mini Breadboard | 1 | 4 | 1 | 4 |
10V Power Supply | 1 | 8.6 | 1 | 8.6 |
Subtotal | 93.3 | Subtotal | 93.3 | |
Total Cost (USD) | 830.11 | 450.55 |
Table 1: Cost comparison of the two configurations of the miniature fluorimeter.
Supplemental File 1: System1_Optics_Enclosure_Top.stl Please click here to download this file.
Supplemental File 2: System1_Optics_Enclosure_Bottom.stl, and Please click here to download this file.
Supplemental File 3: LCD_Screen_Holder.stl Please click here to download this file.
Supplemental File 4: System2_Optics_Enclosure_Top.stl Please click here to download this file.
Supplemental File 5: System2_Optics_Enclosure_Bottom.stl, and Please click here to download this file.
Supplemental File 6: System2_BuildInstructions.pdf Please click here to download this file.
Supplemental Coding File 1: MiniFluorimeter_2Diode.ino Please click here to download this Coding File.
Supplemental Coding File 2: MiniFluorimeter_2Diode_GUI.py Please click here to download this Coding File.
Described here is an open-source, low-cost, modular, portable fluorimeter for quantitative fluorescence detection of isothermal amplification reactions. Open-source projects facilitate rapid and inexpensive maintenance with readily available replacement parts and allow users the flexibility to adapt the system to their needs based on modular design. This protocol describes the process of assembling mechanical, optical and electrical components, and validating optical performance. Furthermore, the flexibility of the fluorimeter to monitor two different types of isothermal amplification assays with significantly different temperature, volume, and fluorescence requirements, RPA exo and RT-LAMP, was demonstrated. RPA is performed at 39 °C in 50 µL reactions that utilize a sequence-specific FAM-tagged probe for fluorescence generation, while RT-LAMP is performed at 65 °C in a 25 µL reaction volume and uses an intercalating dye to report the presence of the amplified DNA. Because fluorescence measurements are made through the top of PCR tubes with flat caps, the fluorimeter is able to detect fluorescence from both assay volumes, and heat requirements are only limited by the commercial heat block chosen. Furthermore, the fluorescence intensity produced in RT-LAMP is almost in the order of magnitude greater than that produced in RPA, due to the dye- versus probe-based methods of fluorescence signal generation. However, the dynamic range of the optical sensor chosen can detect and quantify both the signals, and baseline subtraction algorithms account for these differences to produce reliable fluorescence readings.
To facilitate technology dissemination and minimize potential maintenance cost, a modular design that is compatible with heaters that are widely available in different settings was employed. In the current protocol, a common dry block heater was used; the same optical and electrical design can be readily adapted for other commercially available heaters. If another dry block heater is to be used, minimal changes in the 3D housing design will be required. Specifically, the bottom pegs of the optical enclosure STL files must be modified to ensure proper alignment with the wells of other commercial heat blocks. While the enclosures shown in the examples were printed on a relatively low-end 3D printer (see Table of Materials), care should be taken to ensure the printer resolution and/or print tolerances are adequate to accommodate the optical components and threaded inserts. In the STL files provided, a tolerance of 0.01-0.02 inches was added on either side of the optical components in the radial and axial directions based on the dimensions specified by the manufacturer. This ensures all optical components fit securely within the print and that the enclosure completely blocks excess light from entering or escaping. To ensure a proper press fit for the threaded inserts, a similar tolerance of 0.01-0.02 inches was subtracted from the manufacturer-provided diameter in the CAD file.
RPA reactions were successfully monitored using the first fluorimeter configuration, while RT-LAMP reactions could be monitored using either configuration. The improved stray light rejection of the first configuration was necessary to monitor the low levels of fluorescence produced by the fluorogenic probe in RPA reactions. In contrast, RT-LAMP utilizes an intercalating dye for signal generation, resulting in a higher fluorescence intensity that is compatible with the lower dynamic range of the second configuration using photographic filter foils. Users should select the fluorimeter configuration that matches the fluorescence signal generating element-intercalating dye or fluorogenic probe-of their assay.
One limitation of this system is that heating is provided by a commercially available heat block powered through a standard wall outlet. This system could be further developed for use in areas lacking reliable access to electricity by incorporating portable and rechargeable battery packs as shown by other groups12. Another limitation is the relatively low throughput of the system, which allows for simultaneous fluorescence measurement of only two samples at a time. Multiple prints of the enclosure can be placed atop the same heat block to increase throughput; however, the light sensor used only has four unique I2C addresses. This restricts the maximum number of samples that can be simultaneously measured to four. A different light sensor with a larger number of unique I2C addresses is needed to further increase throughput.
Special thanks to Chelsey Smith, Megan Chang, Emilie Newsham, Sai Paul, and Christopher Goh for their assistance with sample preparation. The authors thank Caroline Noxon for manuscript revision. Funding for this work was provided from the American people by USAID through an IAVI research grant CCID 9204 under award AID-OAA-A16-00032 between IAVI and USAID.
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
1/4-inch-long 4-40 threaded insert | McMaster-Carr | 90742A116 | Used to secure the two sides of the 3D printed optical enclosure together. |
10v power supply | GlobTek, Inc. | WR9HU1800CCP-F(R6B) | AC/DC Wall Mount Adapter 10V 18W |
15 mm focal length lens | Thorlabs | LA 1074 | Two total are used for the fluorimeter. This lens is used to focus the LED illumination. |
1-inch-long 4-40 screws | McMaster-Carr | ||
20 mm focal length lens | Thorlabs | LA 1540 | Four total are used for the fluorimeter. |
2x WarmStart LAMP Master Mix | New England Biolabs, Inc | E1700 | Master mix was used to create the LAMP reactions shown in Figure 3C |
3.5” Touch Screen | Uctronics | BO10601 | |
3/16-inch-long 4-40 screw | McMaster-Carr | 90128A105 | |
3/16-inch-long 4-40 threaded insert | McMaster-Carr | 90742A115 | Used to secure the OPT3002 test board onto the 3D printed enclosure |
3/8-inch-long 4-40 screws | McMaster-Carr | 90128A108 | Used to secure the two sides of the 3D printed optical enclosure together. |
3D printer filament | 3D Universe | UMNFC-PC285-BLACK | Black or another dark color preferred |
3D printer used | Ultimaker | Ultimaker 2+ | |
8-tube PCR strips | BioRad | #TLS0801 | |
Advanced Mini Dry Block Heater | VWR International | 10153-320 | The following heat blocks are acceptable substitutes without the need for redesigning the optical assembly: 949VWMNLUS, 949VWMHLUS, and 949VWMHLEU |
barrel jack to two-pin adapter | SparkFun Electronics | 1568-1238-ND | |
Blue Excitation Filter Foil | LEE | LE071S | Selected for use with FITC - other fluorescent dyes may require different filters. |
Blue LED - 460 nm | Mouser | LZ1-30DB00-0100 | Selected for use with FITC - other fluorescent dyes may require different parts |
Dichroic Mirror | Thorlabs | DMLP505T | Selected for use with FITC - other fluorescent dyes may require different parts |
Emission Filter | Edmunds Optics | OG-515 | Selected for use with FITC - other fluorescent dyes may require different parts. The arrow on the part points away from the illumination source. |
Excitation Filter | Omega Filters | 490AESP | Selected for use with FITC - other fluorescent dyes may require different parts |
LED Driver | LEDdynamics | 3021-D-I-700 | |
M2.5 Hex Shaped insert | McMaster-Carr | 91292A009 | Used to secure the Raspberry Pi to the 3D printed LCD Screen Holder |
Microcontroller | Arduino | Nano | |
Mini Breadboard | Adafruit | 65 | |
Molecular biology-grade mineral oil | Sigma Aldrich | 69794 | |
OPT3002EVM - Light-to-Digital Sensor | Texas Instruments | OPT3002EVM: | Light-to-digital sensor used. Consists of two PCBs: a SM-USB_DIG board and the OPT3002 test board; only the OPT3002 test board is needed for this device. |
Purchased oligonucleotides | Integrated DNA Technologies | ||
RPA kit positive control DNA | TwistDx Limited | CONTROL01DNAE | |
SARS-CoV-2 RNA Control | Twist Biosciences | MN908947.3 | |
Single board computer | Raspberry Pi | Raspberry Pi 3 | |
TwistAmp RPA exo kit | TwistDx Limited | TAEXO02KIT | |
Ultraclear flat caps | BioRad | #TCS0803 | |
Yellow Emmission Filter Foil | LEE | LE767S | Selected for use with FITC - other fluorescent dyes may require different parts |
This article has been published
Video Coming Soon
ABOUT JoVE
Copyright © 2024 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved