This protocol describes a method to induce an accurate and reproducible corneal and limbal alkali injury in a mouse model. The protocol is advantageous as it allows for an evenly distributed injury to the highly curved mouse cornea and limbus.
The cornea is critical for vision, and corneal healing after trauma is fundamental in maintaining its transparency and function. Through the study of corneal injury models, researchers aim to enhance their understanding of how the cornea heals and develop strategies to prevent and manage corneal opacities. Chemical injury is one of the most popular injury models that has extensively been studied on mice. Most previous investigators have used a flat paper soaked in sodium hydroxide to induce corneal injury. However, inducing corneal and limbal injury using flat filter paper is unreliable, since the mouse cornea is highly curved. Here, we present a new instrument, a modified biopsy punch, that enables the researchers to create a well-circumscribed, localized, and evenly distributed alkali injury to the murine cornea and limbus. This punch-trephine method enables researchers to induce an accurate and reproducible chemical burn to the entire murine cornea and limbus while leaving other structures, such as the eyelids, unaffected by the chemical. Moreover, this study introduces an enucleation technique that preserves the medial caruncle as a landmark for identifying the nasal side of the globe. The bulbar and palpebral conjunctiva, and lacrimal gland are also kept intact using this technique. Ophthalmologic examinations were performed via slit lamp biomicroscope and fluorescein staining on days 0, 1, 2, 6, 8, and 14 post-injury. Clinical, histological, and immunohistochemical findings confirmed limbal stem cell deficiency and ocular surface regeneration failure in all experimental mice. The presented alkali corneal injury model is ideal for studying limbal stem cell deficiency, corneal inflammation, and fibrosis. This method is also suitable for investigating pre-clinical and clinical efficacies of topical ophthalmologic medications on the murine corneal surface.
The cornea is critical for vision and exhibits unique characteristics, including transparency, which is a prerequisite for clear vision. In addition to serving a major protective role, the cornea accounts for 2/3 of the refractive power of the eye1. Due to its significant role in vision, corneal injuries and opacity cause significant visual decline and are responsible for the second-highest cause of preventable blindness worldwide2,3. In corneal injuries with severe limbal dysfunction, the barrier function of the limbus decreases, resulting in the migration of conjunctival cells toward the corneal surface and corneal conjunctivalization4,5, which compromises vision dramatically. Effective preventive and therapeutic strategies are therefore required to address the global burden of corneal blindness and related disability.
The current understanding of the human corneal wound healing process is based on previous studies that have investigated corneal responses to various injuries. Several techniques and animal models have been employed to induce various chemical or mechanical corneal injuries6,7,8,9 and to investigate various aspects of the corneal wound healing process.
The alkali burn model is a well-established injury model which is performed by applying sodium hydroxide (NaOH) over the corneal surface directly or by using flat filter paper10. An alkali injury results in the release of pro-inflammatory mediators and infiltration of polymorphonuclear cells not only in the cornea and anterior chamber of the eye but also in the retina. This induces unintended retinal ganglion cell apoptosis and CD45+ cell activation11. Therefore, it is critical to localize the injury site precisely to avoid excessive unintended injury using an alkali injury model.
The axial length of the murine eyeball is approximately 3 mm12. Due to this short distance between the cornea and the retina, a steep corneal curvature exists to provide high refractive power to focus the light on the retina (Figure 1A). As we previously reported13, inducing chemical injury to this highly-curved surface using a flat filter paper is difficult, particularly at the limbus (Figure 1B). Inducing injury to the limbus requires tilting the filter paper, which has the potential to cause unintended injury to the fornix and adjacent conjunctiva14. Another approach involves directly applying the chemical agent as drops onto the corneal surface. However, this method lacks control over the exposure time, and there is a potential risk of inducing injury to the conjunctiva, fornix, and eyelids due to the diffusion of the liquid to these areas.
To overcome these limitations, this study presents a novel punch-trephine method to induce injury. This technique has several advantages including (i) inducing an effective chemical injury to the entire corneal surface and limbus in mouse model, (ii) inducing a localized and well-circumscribed injury to the cornea, (iii) the ability to apply any liquid of interest for a predetermined duration, and (iv) the ability to induce different sizes of corneal injuries by selecting appropriate biopsy punches. This method is also feasible for rat and rabbit injury models, which also exhibit a curved corneal surface and are common animal models used to study ocular surface wound healing.
All procedures were carried out in accordance with the Stanford laboratory animal care APLAC number 33420, use of animals for scientific purposes, and the ARVO Statement for the use of animals in ophthalmic and vision research. A total of 10 male and female C57BL/6 mice aged 8-12 weeks were generously provided by the Irving L. Weissman laboratory. The animals were acclimatized to a 12 h light-dark cycle and provided with water and feed ad libitum. Injury was induced to one eye of the animal.
1. Preparation for the experiment
2. Animal preparation
3. Induction of alkali injury
4. Clinical evaluation
5. Enucleation
6. Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) and periodic acid-Schiff (PAS) staining
7. Immunofluorescence imaging and analysis
The efficacy of the method in inducing limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) was assessed by evaluating the clinical and histological signs of LSCD. Clinical assessment was done by slit-lamp microscopy and anterior segment- optical coherence tomography (AS-OCT) imaging (Figure 3 and Figure 4).
Re-epithelialization occurred in a centripetal manner and was faster at the temporal part of the cornea compared to its nasal part. Injured eyes developed 2+-3+ corneal haze immediately after chemical injury (Figure 3). Epithelial cells migrated from the conjunctiva to the corneal surface following limbal injury. The large corneal epithelial defect was re-epithelialized completely on days 12-14, which took longer compared to a corneal epithelial injuryof similar size and intact basement membrane and stroma which typically healed within 5 days post-injury8,9. Due to LSCD, 50% of the injured eyes developed persistent epithelial defects at the end of second week (Figure 3). Corneal edema was more prominent during the first few days (Figure 3, Figure 4), whereas corneal fibrosis was significant in the second week that resulted in 4+ corneal opacity in 100% of injured eyes.
Early signs of neovascularization (NV) were observed clinically and histologically, 24 h after chemical injury induction, as illustrated in Figure 5, consistent with the timeline of NV identified by Kvanta et al. study that showed sign of limbal NV 24 h after injury22. During the healing process, new vessels matured and by the 14th day after injury, NV crossed the limbus and reached the central cornea. The limbus, which defines the boundary between the conjunctiva and cornea, was destroyed.
Histological evidence of limbal stem cell deficiency and conjunctivalization were observed by the appearance of PAS+ goblet cells and stromal blood vessels23,24,25,26. Goblet cells were observed in the present injury model and indicated by the arrow in Figure 6.
Conjunctival and corneal epithelia principally express unique keratins, K13 and K12, respectively27. After the limbal injury, new epithelial cells that originated from the conjunctiva covered the denuded cornea, and K12 was not expressed on the corneal surface of any injured animals during 2 weeks after injury. This finding, consistent with other studies28, indicated complete LSCD and the absence of corneal epithelial cells on the corneal surface. However, in the study by Park et al.29, they detected K12 expression 20 and 32 weeks after injury, suggesting a possible trans-differentiation of the epithelial cells.
Consequently, we observed that chemical injury destroyed the limbus and limbal stem cells which resulted in the migration of conjunctival epithelial cells to the center of the cornea to cover the denuded corneal surface. This is further validated by the conjunctival epithelial cell marker, K13, which was expressed in the entire conjunctiva and corneal surfaces as shown in Figure 7.
Figure 1: Normal mouse right eye and the punch-trephine for inducing corneal and limbal injury. (A) Lateral view showing mouse eye with highly curved cornea (arrowheads indicate the limbus). (B) The image demonstrates that even a large filter paper is insufficient to adequately cover the limbal area. The limbus-to-limbus diameter of the mouse eye is almost 4 mm and a punch biopsy with an external diameter of 4.5 mm and internal diameter of 3.5 mm (panels D and H), appropriately covers the cornea and limbal surface as shown in panels (C) and (E). (F) The punch-trephine is appropriately held over the globe around the limbal area. (G) To ensure that there is no leakage through the edge of the punch-trephine, after appropriately positioning the punch-trephine in a parallel axis with the globe, the hole is filled with methylene blue. No leakage of methylene blue is detected. Scale bar = 1 mm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Enucleated eyes. (A) The eyes were enucleated while preserving the bulbar and palpebral conjunctiva, the lacrimal gland (arrowhead), and the optic nerve (arrow). The normal (B) and injured (C) eyes were saturated in 30% sucrose to protect against cryocrystal formation. The nasal part of the globe is recognizable through the nasal caruncle (labelled N). Scale bar = 1 mm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Wound healing of the left eye. The wound healing process of the left mouse eye throughout 2 weeks after corneal and limbal alkali injury in a mouse model is shown here (A-F). The slit lamp examination of the eye. Corneal edema is more prominent on days 0 and 2 (A,B), whereas fibrosis is more evident during the second-week post-injury (E-F). A.f-F.f show the re-epithelialization process of the same eye. Total corneal and limbal epithelial defect immediately after injury induction is observed in A.f. The epithelial defect healed by conjunctival epithelial cell migration in a centripetal pattern by 12-14 days (A.f-F.f). However, 50% of the injured eyes developed persistent epithelial defect at the end of second week as shown by arrow in F and F.f images. Scale bar = 1 mm (panel C). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Anterior segment OCT of the mouse eye. (A) AS-OCT illustrates normal cornea curvature and anterior chamber. The iris structure is well-defined and recognizable. No iridocorneal adhesion is detectable at the mid-periphery of the iris. (B) Immediately after injury the corneal thickness increases due to edema formation and iridocorneal adhesion develops at the mid periphery of the iris. (C) Two weeks after injury the corneal curvature has changed and total iridocorneal adhesion with anterior chamber destruction is visible. Scale bar = 1 mm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Corneal neovascularization. Clinical and histological signs of corneal neovascularization can be observed during the wound healing process following sodium hydroxide (NaOH) injury. (A) The initial signs of neovascularization become detectable on the first day after injury, characterized by a reddish discoloration of the cornea (indicated by a white arrow). This discoloration results from the aggregation of red blood cells in the stroma, as illustrated in corresponding histological image (D) (indicated by yellow arrowheads). (B) Over the first week of regeneration, new vessels progressively increase and spread throughout the cornea. (C) By the end of 2 weeks, the limbal area is destroyed, and the new vessels continue to evolve. (E) The histological section of the cornea further illustrates the presence of deep stromal neovascularization (shown by arrowheads). Slit lamp Image scale bar = 1 mm, the histology image scale bar = 50 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Periodic acid-Schiff and immunohistochemical (IHC) staining of cornea. Periodic acid-Schiff and immunohistochemical staining of the normal and injured cornea was done 2 weeks post-injury. Normal mouse corneal epithelium composed of 4-5 layers of cells (A). Alkali injury to the cornea and limbus led to conjunctivalization of the cornea with appearance of goblet cells on the corneal surface as shown by black arrows in (D). Normal corneal epithelial cells express K12 (B), which is not expressed by the conjunctival cells that cover the injured cornea (E). K13, a characteristic marker of conjunctival epithelial cells, is not expressed on the normal corneal epithelial cells (C). However, it is present on the sodium hydroxide (NaOH) injured corneal surface that is a sign of corneal conjunctivalization (F). Histology image scale bar = 50 µm, IHC stained image scale bar = 20 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Hematoxylin and eosin and immunohistochemical staining. Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) and immunohistochemical staining of the normal and injured limbus tissue was done. (A) The normal limbus marks the transition area between the end of the sclera and the beginning of the cornea. This region is typically covered by one or two layers of conjunctival epithelial cells (indicated by the arrows). In a healthy eye, the expression of a specific corneal epithelial marker called K12 begins at the limbus and extends to the surface of the cornea (shown in image B). On the other hand, the expression of a conjunctival marker known as K13 is restricted to the limbus and does not extend beyond it (indicated by the white arrow in image C). In eyes injured by sodium hydroxide (NaOH), the boundaries of the limbus are disrupted. This leads to migration of conjunctival cells towards the injured cornea. (D) The images of the NaOH-injured limbus demonstrate the presence of neovascularization both beneath the epithelial layer and within the stromal tissue. Following the injury, the injured corneal surface lacks the presence of K12 (E), while K13 is abundantly expressed on the corneal surface (F). Histology image scale bar = 50 µm, IHC stained image scale bar = 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplementary File 1: Staining protocol. Please click here to download this File.
Video 1: NaOH corneal and limbal injury in a mouse model with a punch-trephine. The video demonstrates the procedure of inducing NaOH corneal and limbal injury in a mouse model with a punch-trephine. It is crucial to hold the punch-trephine in a parallel axis with the globe and apply minimal pressure to the limbus. This proper technique is essential to prevent leakage and achieve optimal results. Please click here to download this Video.
Video 2: Illustration of the enucleation technique while preserving the bulbar conjunctiva. To differentiate the nasal side of the globe from the temporal side, the nasal caruncle is preserved along with the globe. The entire conjunctiva is dissected starting from its junction to the tarsal plate. With minimal pressure, the orbital contents protrude outward. By guiding the forceps toward the back of the globe, the optic nerve is grasped, and the tissue is extracted. The enucleated tissue includes the globe, orbital fat, and orbital lacrimal gland. Please click here to download this Video.
This study proposes an innovative device, the punch-trephine, which can be used to successfully induce an effective and reproducible corneal and limbal injury in a mouse model. This limbal stem cell deficiency model is ideal to investigate the dynamics of corneal wound healing and conjunctivalization after injury.
Evidence suggests that both the limbal niche and central part of the murine cornea contain stem cells30. Therefore, an efficient corneal and limbal injury is required to produce a stem cell deficiency model, and the injury model presented here enables exposure of the curved corneal limbus to a chemical agent for a specific period. To determine the best concentration and duration of NaOH injury, injuries were inflicted with various NaOH concentrations and durations. Higher NaOH concentrations or longer exposure durations resulted in increased tissue damage and fibrosis. Therefore, researchers can adjust these parameters based on the specific goals of their study and the desired severity of injury.
To successfully reproduce this corneal and limbal injury model, several key considerations should be considered. First, it is imperative to measure the limbal-to-limbal diameter of the targeted eye to determine the appropriate size of the punch. Selecting a biopsy punch with an external diameter that is 0.5 - 1 mm larger than this diameter is recommended.
The surface tension of the liquid used is an important factor in preventing leakage at the interface between the ocular surface and the edge of the punch trephine as shown in Figure 1G. Therefore, there is no need to apply pressure to the tip of the punch biopsy.
To avoid causing mechanical damage to the tissue, it is critical to hold the punch trephine in a parallel axis with the eye and refrain from applying pressure to the limbus. Improper adjustment of the punch trephine axis can increase the risk of leakage and result in a decentered site of injury and inaccurate results.
Some potential limitations of this technique include the need to select the appropriate punch size, acquiring proficiency in holding the punch trephine, and the potential risk of causing mechanical injury. However, these limitations can be overcome through practice and by following the instructions outlined in this protocol. The strain and the age range of the mice are other factors that affect the re-epithelialization process and must be considered in the study.
Moreover, the proposed protocol is advantageous as it details an enucleation method that preserves the bulbar and palpebral conjunctiva and allows for the determination of the nasal part of the globe without the application of surgical sutures as a marker. Previous research has indicated that the nasal region of the eye possesses the lowest neural innervation compared to other areas of the cornea, which makes it more vulnerable to neovascularization and reduced regenerative efficacy31,32.
In summary, the clinical signs of LSCD, such as corneal opacity (CO), persistent epithelial defects, and corneal neovascularization (NV), along with the observed histological changes, including goblet cell metaplasia, expression of K13 on the corneal surface, and absence of K12 on the corneal surface, confirm the presence of LSCD in this model. These findings provide evidence that this novel technique is effective in inducing LSCD. This chemical injury model can be employed in preclinical studies to investigate new medications and pharmaceutical treatments in the field of corneal injury and regeneration.
We acknowledge that NEI P30-EY026877 supports this research. We greatly acknowledge Charlene Wang and the Dr. Irv Weissman Lab at Stanford University's Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine for all their kind assistance in providing experimental animals. We appreciate Hirad Rezaeipoor's assistance in the preparation and editing of the images.
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Anti-K12 antibody | ABCAM | ab185627 | |
Anti-K13 antibody | ABCAM | ab92551 | |
Bovine serum albumin (BSA) | ThermoFisher Scientific | B14 | |
C57BL/6 mice | Dr Weissman Lab, Stanford University | ||
Curved forceps | Storz | E1885 | |
Disposable 90 degree bent needle | |||
Disposable biopsy punch | Med blades | ||
Donkey anti-rabbit IgG H&L | ABCAM | ab150073 | |
Ethanol | ThermoFisher Scientific | T038181000CS | |
Ethiqa XR (Buprenorphine extended-release injectable suspension) | Fidelis Animal Health | ||
Heating pad for mouse | |||
Ketamine hydrochloride | Ambler | ANADA 200-055 | |
OCT | Tissue-Tek 4583 | ||
Ophthalmic surgical scissors | |||
pH Indicator Sticks | Whatman | ||
Phosphate buffered saline (PBS) | ThermoFisher Scientific | AM9624 | |
Prolong gold antifade reagent with DAPI | Invitrogen | P36935 | |
Slit-lamp microscope | NIDEK | SL-450 | |
Sodium fluorescein AK-fluor 10% | Dailymed | NDC17478-253-10 | |
Sterile irrigation solution (BSS) | Alcon | 9017036-0119 | |
Sterile syringe, 1 and 5 ml | |||
Straight forceps | Katena K5 | 4550- Storz E1684 | |
Surgical eye spears | American White 17240 Cross | ||
Surgical microscope | Zeiss S5 microscope | ||
Tetracaine ophthalmic drop | Alcon  |  NDC0065-0741-14 | |
Timer | |||
Triple antibiotic ophthalmic ointment | Bausch and Lomb | ||
TritonX -100 | Fisher Scientific  | 50-295-34 | |
Two-speed rotary tool | 200-1/15 Two Speed Rotary Toolkit | ||
Xylazine | AnaSed | NADA#139-236 |
This article has been published
Video Coming Soon
ABOUT JoVE
Copyright © 2024 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved