Method Article
This article describes a protocol for multiplex immunofluorescence optimized to characterize the three-dimensional architecture of peritoneal metastases.
The spatial heterogeneity of the tumor microenvironment (TME) is a critical determinant of therapeutic response, particularly for immune-oncology agents, where success depends on the distribution of specific immune cell subpopulations. Over the past decade, multiple sophisticated technologies have been introduced to achieve detailed resolution of the TME using two-dimensional sections from either formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) or fixed-frozen tissues. While these thin sections are easier to procure and analyze, they lack the three-dimensional architecture needed to reliably and comprehensively characterize a tumor. To address this limitation, a tissue mounting and imaging technique was developed to enable the three-dimensional analysis of tumor lesions in their native in vivo state. This protocol outlines the procurement of human tumor tissue, the mounting of samples on custom-printed platforms, and staining procedures for post-fixation samples. The multiplexed immunofluorescence technique, IBEX (Iterative Bleaching Extends Multiplexity), was adapted to characterize the three-dimensional TME with up to 15 markers for tumor, immune, and stromal cells using commercially available antibodies. Imaging depths of up to 100 µm were achieved using an inverted white-light laser confocal microscope with a custom-printed imaging adaptor and commercial glass-bottom dishes to ensure optimal tissue orientation. This protocol highlights the potential of the IBEX method to expand multiplexed immunofluorescence studies, providing a more comprehensive understanding of TME composition.
Solid tumors are highly variable, with an intricate composition of cell types (malignant and non-malignant), extracellular matrix proteins, and soluble factors1,2. Ultimately, this highly complex, heterogeneous tumor microenvironment (TME) determines susceptibility to treatments like immunotherapy3,4. As such, technologies as highly multiplexed immunofluorescence5,6 and spatial transcriptomics7 have been applied to characterize the complexity of the TME in cell layer-thick (~4 µM) sections.
As opposed to cell dispersion approaches such as single-cell sequencing and flow cytometry8,9,10, these techniques preserve spatial relationships to contribute critical information about cellular crosstalk and can be employed to identify potential biomarkers for prediction of treatment response11,12,13. However, tumor lesions are inherently three-dimensional (3D) structures, and 2D approaches like those mentioned above do not adequately capture the complex cellular landscape. The importance of 3D biology has been appreciated in the field, as evidenced by the wide utilization of patient-derived tumor organoid cultures14. However, organoids do not retain the cellular complexity of the original in vivo TME, which limits applicability for use with immunomodulatory drugs or for characterization of the diverse TME cell populations.
Although it may be possible to perform analyses on serial 2D sections and computationally "stitch" the images together for a 3D rendering, this technique is cost-prohibitive and challenging to accomplish with high fidelity15. To cost-effectively characterize 3D tissues (e.g., tumors) in a reproducible manner, a unique method for the preparation and multiplex immunofluorescence staining/analysis was developed and demonstrated using peritoneal tumor lesions from a patient with primary peritoneal cancer.
Based on an adaptation of the well-established IBEX technique (Iterative Bleaching Extends Multiplexity)16,17, this protocol details 3D-printing of a tissue holder and imaging adapter, peritoneal tissue procurement, and mounting, multiple cycles of staining with various tumor and cell-type markers, and high-resolution confocal 3D-imaging.
The study was conducted with approval from the National Institutes of Health Institutional Review Board under protocol NCT01915225. Human tissue was obtained with written informed consent at the time of diagnostic laparoscopy. All tissue was tumor-bearing, as determined by visible inspection and confirmed through final histopathologic examination. Details of all reagents and equipment used are listed in the Table of Materials. A schematic illustration of the entire workflow is provided in Figure 1.
1. Printing platforms, imaging adaptor, and incubation plate
2. Tissue mounting on printed platforms
3. Fixation/staining/bleaching procedure
NOTE: Changes from the original protocol tailored to 4 µm thin FFPE or fixed frozen sections are outlined in Figure 3. Table 1 provides a list of antibodies (with dilutions) used for IBEX rounds 1-6.
4. Imaging procedure
The peritoneum is a membranous structure less than 1 mm thick that lines the surface of the abdominal wall and is contiguous with the surfaces of abdominal organs. It is composed of surface mesothelium and underlying connective tissue that is interspersed with adipose cells, lymphocytes, macrophages, and fibroblasts, as well as blood and lymphatic vessels. Peritoneal malignancies most often stem from abdominal tumor metastases (e.g., ovarian cancer or gastric cancer)18 or, less frequently, can be primary tumors of the peritoneum (e.g., mesothelioma)19. These often small (<1 cm) tumor lesions are highly complex but are amenable to 3D characterization using the technique outlined. A maximum projection of five confocal sections is used to view the entire sample mounted on a platform (Figure 4, inset in upper left corner). Three primary conjugated antibodies (AF488-CD44, AF594-CD45, and AF647-Podoplanin) together with the nuclear dye Hoechst were used for the first round of IBEX (IBEX1, Figure 4). Tumor lesions become evident by the rosette-like structures that are double-positive for CD44 and Podoplanin and show an arrangement of nuclei characteristic of papillary mesothelioma.
Tumor cells were identified using cell morphology and two antibodies since both anti-Podoplanin and anti-CD44 recognize non-tumor cells, as evidenced by the detection of lymphatic vessels via anti-Podoplanin and the binding of the CD44 antibody to subsets of immune cells. Smaller regions of interest (ROIs) are then captured using a tile scan format in higher resolution at optimized Z-step sizes for rendering 3D projections (Figure 5A). Platforms were taken through the iterative staining procedures, and the same ROIs were imaged in IBEX cycles 1-6. Representative images for tumor (yellow box) and tumor-tertiary lymphoid structure (TLS) interfaces (blue box) are assembled in Figure 5B-M.
The presence of TLS and density of CD3-positive cells indicate significant immune cell infiltration20 and possibly responsiveness to immunomodulatory drugs21. Of note, TLS and the bulk of the tumor lesions are present in different Z-depths of the tissue, as demonstrated in comparing stack projections of different optical sections in Figure 6, highlighting the benefits of 3D imaging and the potential missed biology when 2D imaging is applied to 3D structures. The 3D character of these lesions becomes more evident in the movie files (Movie 1-12), which depict volume renderings of the individual lesions in Figure 5.
Figure 1: Workflow from 3D printing to 3D imaging of peritoneal tumors. The protocol consists of a sequence of five steps to prepare 3D multiplexed images from tumor-bearing peritoneal tissue. (1) Printing of tissue-receiving platforms, imaging adaptor parts, and incubation plate. (2) Tissue procurement and mounting procedures. (3) Fixation with paraformaldehyde. (4) IBEX staining and imaging cycles. (5) 3D reconstruction using imaging software. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Hardware components with tissue interface for 3D imaging. (A) Schematic diagram of platform assembly within imaging adaptor. (B) A 9-well incubation plate. (C) Photographs of image adaptor components with assembly. (D) Mesothelioma-bearing peritoneum as observed during diagnostic laparoscopy. (E) Mounting of tissue on the platform. (F,G) Tumor-bearing peritoneum mounted on platforms. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Timeline schematic of IBEX cycles. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Overview of platform following incubation with IBEX1 panel. Maximum projection of the entire platform following incubation with IBEX1 panel (Hoechst, AF488-CD44, AF594-CD45, and AF647-Podoplanin). The dashed circle highlights the tumor. Inset: Photograph of tumor-bearing peritoneum mounted on the imaging platform. Scale bar: 1 mm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: High-resolution immunofluorescence images of select platform regions. (A) Maximum projection of merged 56-tile Z-stack image acquired following incubation with IBEX1 panel (Hoechst, AF488-CD44, AF594-CD45 and AF647-Podoplanin). Yellow rectangle: tumor lesion shown in panels (B-G). Blue rectangle: tumor-tertiary lymphoid structure interface shown in (H-M). (B-G) One individual tumor lesion with IBEX panel 1-6 in volume rendering. (B) IBEX1, green: CD44, red: CD45, cyan: Podoplanin. (C) IBEX2, green: CD20, red: F-actin, cyan: CD3. (D) IBEX3, green: CD8, red: CD4, cyan: panCK. (E) IBEX4, green: CD31, cyan: CD68. (F) IBEX5, green: CD206, cyan: Calretinin. (G) IBEX6, green: Vimentin, red: HLADR. (H-M) One individual tumor-tertiary lymphoid structure interface with IBEX panel 1-6 in volume rendering. (H) IBEX1, green: CD44, red: CD45, cyan: Podoplanin. (I) IBEX2, green: CD20, red: F-actin, cyan: CD3. (J) IBEX3, green: CD4, red: panCK, cyan: CD8. (K) IBEX4, green: CD31, red: SMA, cyan: CD68. (L) IBEX5, green: CD206, cyan: Calretinin. (M) IBEX6, green: HLADR, cyan: Vimentin. All panels, blue: Hoechst. Scale bars: (A, 1 mm); (B-M, 250 µm). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Simulated 2D imaging. Comparison of limited (10 optical sections) and full stack (102 optical sections) projections confirms loss of tissue context in 2D simulation. (A) Maximum projection of sections 30-40 (10 µm). (B) Maximum projection of sections 85-95 (10 µm). (C) Maximum projection of sections 1-102 (~100 µm). All panels, IBEX2 (Hoechst, AF488-CD20, AF647-CD3, AF790-phalloidin). Scale bar: 200 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Table 1: Antibodies used for the individual IBEX panels. Please click here to download this Table.
Movie 1: Animated volume rendering of the individual lesion with IBEX panel 1 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD44, red: CD45, cyan: Podoplanin). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 2: Animated volume rendering of the individual lesion with IBEX panel 2 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD20, red: F-actin, cyan: CD3). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 3: Animated volume rendering of the individual lesion with IBEX panel 3 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD8, red: CD4, cyan: panCK). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 4: Animated volume rendering of the individual lesion with IBEX panel 4 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD31, cyan: CD68). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 5: Animated volume rendering of the individual lesion with IBEX panel 5 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD206, cyan: Calretinin). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 6: Animated volume rendering of the individual lesion with IBEX panel 6 (blue: Hoechst, green: Vimentin, red: HLADR). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 7: Animated volume rendering of tertiary lymphoid structure-lesion interface with IBEX panel 1 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD44, red: CD45, cyan: Podoplanin). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 8: Animated volume rendering of tertiary lymphoid structure-lesion interface with IBEX panel 2 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD20, red: F-actin, cyan: CD3). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 9: Animated volume rendering of tertiary lymphoid structure-lesion interface with IBEX panel 3 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD8, red: CD4, cyan: panCK). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 10: Animated volume rendering of tertiary lymphoid structure-lesion interface with IBEX panel 4 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD31, red: SMA, cyan: CD68). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 11: Animated volume rendering of tertiary lymphoid structure-lesion interface with IBEX panel 5 (blue: Hoechst, green: CD206, cyan: Calretinin). Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 12: Animated volume rendering of tertiary lymphoid structure-lesion interface with IBEX panel 6 (blue: Hoechst, green: Vimentin, red: HLADR). Please click here to download this Movie.
Supplementary File 1: Print file for the incubation plate. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary File 2: Print file for the 36 individual platforms. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary File 3: Print file for the height adjustment ring. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary File 4: Print file for the outer lid. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary File 5: Laser cut file for the slider. Please click here to download this File.
Current multiplex techniques for fluorescence imaging are restricted to thin sections and do not provide 3D context. The present study describes a protocol to apply the IBEX imaging method16,17 to intact tumors mounted on custom-designed platforms. Peritoneal tumor lesions were chosen to highlight the technique as patients commonly present with multiple, ideally sized tumor deposits that are taken along with the surrounding normal peritoneum as part of standard cytoreduction surgery undertaken in most tertiary referral centers across the world22,23. The protocol is nonetheless applicable to parenchymal metastases and mouse model tumors alike using tumor slices as have been previously described24,25. Moreover, the diameter of the mounting ring on the platforms can be adjusted to experimental/tissue needs, although larger areas are prone to tissue sagging and extended imaging times. Irrespective of the tissue source and size, the time between procurement and preservation must be kept minimal to ensure optimal quality26. The setup of a prep table in the operating room guarantees prompt processing when patients are involved. The time from procurement to fixation of the tissue should be noted to ensure comparability between experiments.
Tissue samples are taken through the IBEX protocol as whole mounts, i.e., fixation and imaging as well as bleaching steps, are performed with the intact tissue affixed to the platform. This guarantees sample preservation through the iterative staining/imaging/bleaching cycles, since there is no semi-permanent section-glass interface and no need to repeatedly place/remove a cover glass from the tissue, both of which can lead to tissue loss. To save on reagents, the custom-designed 9-well plate guarantees an optimum fit of the platform with minimal "dead volume". All antibodies used for staining are primary conjugated antibodies, and all fluorophore conjugates used (except for the Hoechst dye) are Alexa Fluor dyes, which were chosen for their excellent brightness27. Other fluorophores Antibody panels were designed according to data deposited from the IBEX imaging community, an open, global repository collecting datasets, protocols, and feedback from an international group of scientists using IBEX (https://ibeximagingcommunity.github.io/ibex_imaging_knowledge_base/). The sequence of antibody panels was carefully chosen. In general, targets with low abundance were placed in earlier cycles. IBEX cycle 1 (CD45, CD44, and Podoplanin) is an exception since these three markers were used to identify tumor lesions in the initial staining round.
Antibody panels are comparably small to reduce channel crosstalk at high laser intensity settings, which is necessary to image the tissue deeper using a confocal microscope. AF750 conjugates were included wherever possible to expand the panel from 2 to 3 antibodies. Of note, there are not many AF750 conjugates commercially available, and the fact that the target for this channel should be highly abundant limits the use of this fluorophore. An example is the AF750-conjugated anti-SMA antibody that was used in this protocol. Although this is a clone that works reliably conjugated to AF488 or AF594, the signal intensity for this antibody conjugated with AF750 is significantly lower, which makes it difficult to generate high-quality Z-stacks.
Antibody incubations of 3 h at room temperature are short compared to the original protocol and reflect most likely the lower cell density in peritoneal tissue samples. In contrast, the bleaching step with 1.5 mg/mL lithium borohydride for 60 min was more stringent. These parameters were determined empirically and can vary with tissue and antibodies being used. Of note is that due to incubation in the reactive bleaching solution, small air bubbles can be trapped in the tissue. Whenever this became evident during the imaging step of the procedure, samples were degassed by exposing the platform in the 9-well incubation plate to vacuum using a suction canister. Simple ITK sample registrations, often applied in IBEX studies, could not be performed due to overwhelming data input to the image analysis software. Nonetheless, identical cell populations are easily identified by comparing individual datasets. Overall, the iterative cycles were timed such that one cycle could be completed in one day, with imaging taking up most of an entire cycle (~ 8 h).
The technique does have limitations that deserve mention. The time requirement of the protocol makes this method unlikely to be adopted broadly but rather in select circumstances. We envision this protocol best utilized to characterize changes in the tumor immune microenvironment pre- and post-treatment (e.g., bispecific antibodies for cancer immunotherapy) or to predict general treatment outcomes. Although this protocol offers 3D characterization, it is not known how much area must be interrogated to effectively describe a tumor, including its complex cell populations28. Access to fresh human tissue may also be difficult in certain centers, but we envision this protocol is applicable to animal models as well29.
The applications for this protocol are diverse, from basic research analyzing the TME composition across multiple solid tumors to pre/ post-tissue biopsies for patients enrolled in clinical trials. Although the data obtainable from a single cell-layer thick tissue section is immense, 3D biology can be easily overlooked. We see 3D imaging as an adjunct to other spatial biology techniques, likely aiding in the selection of 2D sections for subsequent analyses. Additionally, a protocol to incorporate a live imaging component over multiple hours using the described tissue mounting and imaging setup is actively ongoing.
None.
This research was supported by the Intramural Research Program of the National Institutes of Health and the National Cancer Institute (NCI). This research was also partially supported by the CAT-I, a research collaboration between NIAID and NCI, led by Ronald Germain. We would like to extend our gratitude to Andrea Radtke for her enthusiastic, collaborative efforts. Her expertise greatly benefited this study.
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Alexa Fluor Plus 750 Phalloidin | Invitrogen | A30105 | F-actin dye |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-human CD206 (MMR) Antibody | BioLegend | 321114 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-human CD31 Antibody | BioLegend | 303110 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-human CD4 Antibody | BioLegend | 300519 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-human HLA-DR Antibody | BioLegend | 307656 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-mouse/human CD44 Antibody | BioLegend | 103016 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 594 anti-human CD45 Antibody | BioLegend | 304060 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 647 Anti-Calretinin antibody [EP1798] | Abcam | ab214244 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 647 anti-human CD3 Antibody | BioLegend | 300416 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 647 anti-human CD8 Antibody | BioLegend | 344726 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 647 anti-human Podoplanin Antibody | BioLegend | 337007 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 647 anti-Vimentin Antibody | BioLegend | 677807 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 647 CD68 Antibody (KP1) | Santa Cruz | sc-20060AF647 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 750 Cytokeratin, pan Antibody (AE-1/AE-3) | Novus | NBP2-33200AF750 | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 750 Human alpha-Smooth Muscle Actin Antibody | R&D | IC1420S | antibody |
Alexa Fluor 488 CD20 Monoclonal Antibody (L26) eBioscience | Thermo Fisher | 53-0202-82 | antibody |
Antibiotic-Antimycotic | Gibco | 15240096 | supplement harvest medium |
BioMed Clear Resin (Form 3) | FormLabs | RS-F2-BMCL-01 | resin used for platform + incubation plate |
BSA | Sigma | A7906-500g | blocking solution component |
Cast acrylic 1/32" thick | material used for cutting slider | ||
CleanStation DT3 | Stratasys | DT3 | post processing for height adjuster & outer lid |
Container, Specimen | McKesson | 870203 | transfer of tissue from perating table to prep table |
CorelDraw | CorelDRAW | Software to prepare the vector-based design file for laser cutting | |
Cytofix | BD Bioscience | 554655 | fixative |
Dish 15 cm | Falcon | 353025 | dish used during mounting |
Dish 35 mm No. 1.5 Coverslip 14 mm Glass Diameter Uncoated | Matek | P35G-1.5-14-C | imaging dish |
DMEM (no glucose) | Gibco | 11966025 | harvest medium |
Fc Block | BD Bioscience | 564220 | blocking solution component |
Form 3B+ | Formlabs | Form 3B+ | printer used for platform + incubation plate |
Form Cure | Formlabs | FH-CU-01 | post processing for platform + incubation plate |
Form Wash | Formlabs | FH-WA-01 | post processing for platform + incubation plate |
GrabCAD Print | GrabCAD | GrabCAD Print | Software to prepare models for Stratasys printers |
Hoechst 33342 10 mg/mL | Biotium | 40046 | nuclear dye |
J826 Prime 3D Printer | Stratasys | J826 | printer used for height adjuster & outer lid |
LAS X | Leica | LAS X | Confocal software |
Laser cutting system | Universal Laser Systems | ULS PLS6.150D | CO2 Laser cutting used for slider |
Lithium Borohydride | STREM Chemicals | 93-0397 | bleaching chemical |
PBS, pH 7.4 | Gibco | 10010023 | base Buffer for washing, blocking, staining |
PreForm | FormLabs | PreForm | Software to prepare models for Formlab printers |
Silk sutures 2-0 | Ethicon | A305.O35 | affix tissue to platform |
Stellaris 8 WLL confocal microscope | Leica | STELLARIS 8 | Confocal Imaging |
Syringe filter | filter ab solution | ||
Triton X-100 | American Bio | AB02025-00100 | permeabelizing reagent, blocking solution component |
Vero ContactClear | Stratasys | CTT610, 4 KG | resin used for height adjuster & outer lid |
Warming Tray | Spring USA | ST-1220 | keep media and tissue warm |
Water, distilled | Gibco | 15230-170 | diluent for LiBH4 |
Request permission to reuse the text or figures of this JoVE article
Request PermissionThis article has been published
Video Coming Soon
Copyright © 2025 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved