A subscription to JoVE is required to view this content. Sign in or start your free trial.
Method Article
This article details the manufacturing process for chimeric antigen receptor T cells for clinical use, specifically using an automated cell processor capable of performing viral transduction and cultivation of T cells. We provide recommendations and describe pitfalls that should be considered during the process development and implementation of an early-phase clinical trial.
Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-T cells represent a promising immunotherapeutic approach for the treatment of various malignant and non-malignant diseases. CAR-T cells are genetically modified T cells that express a chimeric protein that recognizes and binds to a cell surface target, resulting in the killing of the target cell. Traditional CAR-T cell manufacturing methods are labor-intensive, expensive, and may carry the risk of contamination. The CliniMACS Prodigy, an automated cell processor, allows for manufacturing cell therapy products at a clinical scale in a closed system, minimizing the risk of contamination. Processing occurs semi-automatically under the control of a computer and thus minimizes human involvement in the process, which saves time and reduces variability and errors.
This manuscript and video describes the T cell transduction (TCT) process for manufacturing CAR-T cells using this processor. The TCT process involves CD4+/CD8+ T cell enrichment, activation, transduction with a viral vector, expansion, and harvest. Using the Activity Matrix, a functionality that allows ordering and timing of these steps, the TCT process can be customized extensively. We provide a walk-through of CAR-T cell manufacturing in compliance with current Good Manufacturing Practice (cGMP) and discuss required release testing and preclinical experiments that will support an Investigational New Drug (IND) application. We demonstrate the feasibility and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of using a semi-automatic process for clinical CAR-T cell manufacturing. Finally, we describe an ongoing investigator-initiated clinical trial that targets pediatric B-cell malignancies [NCT05480449] as an example of how this manufacturing process can be applied in a clinical setting.
Adoptive transfer of T cells engineered to express a chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) has shown remarkable efficacy in treating patients with refractory B-cell malignancies1,2,3,4,5. However, the traditional manufacturing methods for CAR-T cells are labor-intensive, time-consuming, and require highly trained technicians to carry out highly specialized steps. For example, the traditional manufacturing process of an autologous CAR-T cell product involves density gradient centrifugation, elutriation or magnetic separation to enrich T cells, activation, and transduction with a viral vector in a sterile flask, and expansion in a bioreactor prior to harvest and formulation. Various systems have emerged recently that aim to partially automate this process. For example, the Miltenyi CliniMACS Prodigy (hereafter referred to as the "processor") is an automated cell processing device that can perform many of these steps in an automated fashion6,7,8,9. An in-depth discussion of traditional and automated CAR-T manufacturing methods is presented in a recent review article10.
The processor builds upon the functionality of the CliniMACS Plus, a U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved medical device for the processing of hematopoietic progenitor cells. The processor includes a cell cultivation unit that allows for automated washing, fractionation, and cultivation of cells (Figure 1). The T cell transduction (TCT) process is a preset program within the processor device that largely replicates manual CAR-T cell manufacture. TCT allows for customizable cell processing using a graphical user interface (the "Activity Matrix," Figure 2). Because the processor automates many steps and consolidates the functionality of multiple devices into one machine, it requires less training and specialized troubleshooting skills from technologists. Because all steps are performed within a closed, single-use tubing set, the processor may be operated in facilities with less stringent air-handling infrastructure than would be considered acceptable for an open manufacturing process. For example, we are operating the processor in a facility certified as ISO class 8 (comparable to EU grade C).
Figure 1: CAR-T cell manufacturing using the T cell transduction system. Shown is the processor with the tubing set installed. The tubing set allows for connecting other components such as bags containing processing buffer, culture medium, and lentiviral vector via sterile welding. Once the leukapheresis product is added to the Application bag, it can be labeled with T Cell Selection Beads, passed through the Separation column, and then transferred into the Reapplication bag. Selected cells are then directed to the Cultivation unit of the instrument for culture and activated with the Activation reagent (see Table of Materials). The final product is collected in the Target cell bag. Throughout the process, it is possible to remove samples for quality control aseptically. Grey numbers inside of circles represent the numbered valves on the processor that direct the liquid path through the tubing set. Reproduced with permission from 11. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Activity Matrix. After T cell selection and activation, the remainder of the CAR-T cell manufacturing process is fully customizable. Activities can be added or deleted and scheduled for the appropriate day and time, and the culture volume after the activity can be specified (Volume). For example, the Transduction activity was configured to begin at 10:00 AM on Day 1, and the culture volume at the end of the activity was set as 100 mL. The Activity Matrix can be edited throughout the cultivation period. The status of the process can be monitored on the integrated screen of the processing device. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The aim of this manuscript is to provide a detailed walk-through of manufacturing CAR-T cells using the processor and additionally provide guidance on the in-process and product release testing that will likely be required by regulators to approve an investigational new drug (IND) application. The presented protocol stays close to the vendor's recommended approach and is the underlying protocol for IND 28617, which is currently being evaluated in a single-center investigator-initiated phase I/II clinical trial. This trial aims to determine the safety and efficacy of using this processor to manufacture humanized CD19-directed autologous CAR-T cells for patients with B cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (B-ALL) or B-lineage lymphoblastic lymphoma (B-Lly) [NCT05480449]. The trial started in September 2022 and is planned to enroll up to 89 patients ages 0-29 years with B-ALL or B-Lly. We report some manufacturing results from the trial in the manuscript.
We would like to point out that although the manuscript is presented as a protocol with steps to follow, it should be considered a starting point for others to begin optimizing their own CAR-T cell manufacturing process. A non-comprehensive list of possible variations to the presented protocol includes: using fresh instead of cryopreserved T cells as starting material; using a different method of T cell enrichment or omitting it altogether; using different media and cytokine cocktails such as IL7/IL15 instead of IL2; varying the concentration of human AB serum or omitting it altogether; timing of transduction; using "multi-hit" transductions; varying agitation, culture volumes, and feeding schedule; using different methods of genetic transfer including electroporation of nucleic acids or non-lentiviral vectors; using a different final formulation buffer and/or cryoprotectant; and infusing CAR-T cells fresh instead of cryopreserving for infusion at a later time. These variations may have a significant impact on the cellular composition and potency of the therapeutic product.
Overall Process Step | Process Day | Technical Details | |||
Cell Enrichment | Day 0 | Selection of CD4+/CD8+ T cells | |||
Cell Activation | T cell culture seeding and activation | ||||
Cell Transduction | Day 1 | Lentiviral transduction (100 mL culture volume) | |||
Cell Expansion (followed by cell formulation) | Day 2 | -- | |||
Day 3 | Culture Wash (1 cycle); Shaker activated; Culture volume increases to 200 mL | ||||
Day 4 | -- | ||||
Day 5 | Feed (50 mL); Culture volume reaches final volume of 250 mL | ||||
Day 6 | In-process sample; Media exchange (-125 mL / +125 mL) | ||||
Day 7 | Media exchange (-150 mL / +150 mL) or Harvest | ||||
Day 8 | In-process sample; Media exchange (-150 mL / +150 mL) or Harvest | ||||
Day 9 | Media exchange (-180 mL / +180 mL) or Harvest | ||||
Day 10 | In-process sample; Media exchange (-180 mL / +180 mL) or Harvest | ||||
Day 11 | Media exchange (-180 mL / +180 mL) or Harvest | ||||
Day 12 | Media exchange (-180 mL / +180 mL) or Harvest | ||||
Day 13 | Harvest |
Table 1: Process timeline and overview. This table summarizes the TCT process steps employed in a current clinical trial [NCT05480449]. The process starts with T cell enrichment by CD4+/CD8+ selection, culture seeding, and activation on Day 0, followed by transduction on Day 1. Cells rest for 48 h, followed by a culture wash, an increase of the culture volume to 200 mL, and agitation using a shaking mechanism. On Day 6, the first in-process sample is taken. Cells are harvested once sufficient cells are available for at least three full doses of CAR-T cells (5 × 106 CAR-T cells/kg if the patient is <50 kg, otherwise 2.5 × 108 CAR-T cells) and quality control testing (~2 × 106 CAR-T cells); or once the culture reaches a total of 4-5 x 109 cells. Abbreviations: TCT = T cell transduction; CAR-T = chimeric antigen receptor T cells; MACS = magnetic-activated cell sorting.
All research was performed in compliance with institutional guidelines with approval by the hospital's Institutional Review Board (IRB), and all subjects have provided informed consent for publication of the data collected within the context of the trial.
NOTE: The first section of the Protocol provides a high-level overview of the CAR-T manufacturing process. The remaining sections provide the step-by-step instructions. The protocol describes the workflow using TCT software version 1.4, which is the current version as of this writing. The user interface of other versions of the TCT software may vary.
1. Process timeline and overview (Table 1)
2. Day -1: Preparation and preflight checks
3. Day 0: Tubing set installation
4. T cell enrichment
5. Alternative: Starting with CD4+/CD8+ selected cells
6. Culture setup and programming of the Activity Matrix
7. Day 1: T cell transduction
8. Day 6: First in-process sample
9. Day of harvest (anywhere from day 7 to 13): Harvest and cryopreservation
10. Cryopreservation of CAR-T cells
NOTE: This protocol assumes CAR-T cells are cryopreserved after manufacture and stored until the patient is ready for infusion. While it is possible to infuse freshly manufactured CAR-T cells, this increases the logistical burden as it requires coordinating CAR-T cell manufacturing with CAR-T cell infusion. This may be problematic in case of a manufacturing failure. Especially if the clinical protocol requires lymphodepleting chemotherapy prior to CAR-T infusion, we strongly suggest cryopreserving, because a manufacturing failure may expose the patient to the risk of unnecessary chemotherapy. Regulators may require investigators to demonstrate the product passes all release testing prior to infusion, which may be difficult to achieve without cryopreservation.
11. Examination of procedure performance
NOTE: Throughout the TCT process, several QC samples are drawn from the active culture. Table 2 provides a grid that can help the reader organize the results for reference and calculate procedure performance metrics. The terms below consisting of a letter and a number (e.g., "B4") refer to cells in the grid of this table. The following values are used in the performance calculations: B3 = total nucleated cells (TNC) pre-enrichment; B4 = TNC post-enrichment; E2 = The sum of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells as a percentage of the total cells of the initial apheresis product; E4 = The sum of the CD4+ and CD8+ T cells as a percentage of the total cells post-enrichment; G2 = CD19+ cells as a percentage of the total cells of the initial product; G4 = CD19+ cells as a percentage of the total cells after CD4+/CD8+ enrichment; B10 = TNC of the Active Culture on day of harvest.
Table 2: Procedure performance grid. We provide this grid to help organize in-process test reults needed to calculate procedure performance statistics. Rows represent samples analyzed at various time points during the procedure and are labeled with numbers 1-11. Rows 6-9 can be used to capture results from samples taken after day 6 of cultivation but prior to the day of harvest. Columns represent measured parameters and are labeled with letters A-H. Fields that are shaded gray do not apply. Some additional fields may not apply depending on whether CD4+/CD8+ enrichment is performed as part of the procedure and the length of the cultivation. We suggest writing "N/A" into those fields. Abbreviations: TNC = total nucleated cell count; QC = quality control. Please click here to download this Table.
Results from the initial three CAR-T manufacturing runs of the NCT05480449 trial are presented below in Table 3. The starting material, vector, culture cytokines, and AB serum concentrations were kept consistent for each run. Products were harvested on day 7 or 8. The average daily cell growth was 46% (increase in total cell count), indicating that the TCT process was effective in promoting cell expansion. These results suggest that the processor can produce consistent and reproducible CAR-T cell product...
CAR-T cell therapy has emerged as a promising treatment approach for B-cell and other malignancies. However, traditional CAR-T cell manufacturing methods have several limitations, such as high cost, labor-intensive production, and open steps that increase the risk of contamination. Recently, several semi-automated platforms, including the Miltenyi CliniMACS Prodigy (the "processor"), have emerged to address these limitations. The T cell transduction (TCT) process, integrated into the processor described in this m...
S.K., S.G., and Y.W. have received research support from Miltenyi Biotec.
The authors would like to acknowledge the contributions of several individuals and organizations to this work. The Cell and Gene Therapy Laboratory and the Penn Translational and Correlative Studies Laboratory provided valuable assistance with process development and preparation for IND submissions. Melissa Varghese and Amanda DiNofia contributed to the process development and preparation for IND submissions that underly this manuscript. This work was supported by an Acceleration Grant of the Cell and Gene Therapy Collaborative of the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. The authors would also like to thank Miltenyi Biotec for their technical and research support. Figure 1 is covered by copyright © 2023 Miltenyi Biotec B.V. & Co. KG; all rights reserved.
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
12 x 75 borosilicate tubes | Charles River | TL1000 | |
20 mL Reagent Bag | Miltenyi Biotec | 170-076-631 | |
50 mL Conical Tube | Fisher | 05-539-10 | |
150 mL Transfer Set | Fenwal | 4R2001 | |
2,000 mL Transfer Set | Fenwal | 4R2041 | |
7AAD | Fisher Scientific | BDB559925 | |
Alcohol Prep | Tyco/Healthcare | ||
Bag Access | Medline | 2300E-0500 | |
CD19 APC-Vio770 REAfinity | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-113-643 | |
CD19 CAR Detection Reagent Biotin | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-129-550 | |
CD19 PE | BD | 555413 | |
CD3 APC | BD | 340440 | |
CD4 VioBright FITC REAfinity | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-113-229 | |
CD45 VioBlue REAfinity | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-110-637 | |
CD8 APC-Vio770 REAfinity | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-110-681 | |
Cellometer Reference Beads 10um | Nexcelom | B10-02-020 | |
Cellometer Reference Beads 15um | Nexcelom | B15-02-010 | |
Cellometer Reference Beads 5um | Nexcelom | B05-02-050 | |
Cellometer Slides | Nexcelom | CHT4-SD100-002 | |
CliniMACS CD4 GMP MicroBeads | Miltenyi Biotec | 276-01 | The CD4 reagent |
CliniMACS CD8 GMP MicroBeads | Miltenyi Biotec | 275-01 | The CD8 reagent |
CliniMACS PBS/EDTA Buffer | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-021-201 | The buffer |
DMSO | Origen | CP-10 | |
Freezing Bag 50 mL | Miltenyi Biotec | 200-074-400 | |
Freezing Vial, 1.8 mL | Nunc | 12565171N | |
Freezing Vial, 4.5 mL | Nunc | 12565161N | |
Human AB serum | Valley Biomedical | Sterile filtered, heat inactivated | |
Human Serum Albumin 25% | Grifols | 68516-5216-1 | |
Human Serum Albumin 5% | Grifols | 68516-5214-1 | |
MACS GMP Recombinant Human IL-2 | Miltenyi Biotec | 170-076-148 | The cytokines |
MACS GMP T Cell TransAct | Miltenyi Biotec | 200-076-202 | The activation reagent |
MycoSeq Mycoplasma Detection Kit | Life Technologies | 4460623 | |
Needles, Hypodermic 14G | Medline | SWD200573 | |
Needles, SlideSafe 18G | BD | B-D305918 | |
Pipet tips, 2-200 μL, individually wrapped | Eppendorf | 022492209 | |
Pipet tips, 50-1000 μL, individually wrapped | Eppendorf | 022492225 | |
Pipets 10 mL | Fisher | 13-678-27F | |
Pipets 25 mL | Fisher | 13-675-30 | |
Pipets 5 mL | Fisher | 13-678-27E | |
Plasmalyte-A | Baxter | 2B2544X | The electrolyte solution |
Prodigy TS520 Tubing Set | Miltenyi Biotec | 170-076- 600 | The tubing set |
Sterile Field | Medline | NON21001 | |
Streptavidin PE-Vio770 | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-106-793 | |
Syringe 1 mL | BD | 309628 | |
Syringe 10 mL | BD | 302995 | |
Syringe 3 mL | BD | 309657 | |
Syringe 30 mL | BD | 302832 | |
Syringe 50 mL | BD | 309653 | |
TexMACS GMP Medium | Miltenyi Biotec | 170-076-306 | The medium |
Triple Sampling Adapter | Miltenyi Biotec | 170-076-609 | |
Viral Vector | CHOP Clinical Vector Core | huCART19 | |
Equipment | |||
Biological Safety Cabinet | The Baker Co | ||
Cellometer Auto 2000 | Nexcelom | ||
CliniMACS Prodigy | Miltenyi Biotec | 200-075-301 | The processor |
Controlled Rate Freezer | Planer/Kryosave | ||
Endosafe nexgen-PTS150K | Charles River | ||
Mettler Balance | Mettler | ||
Refrigerated Centrifuge | Thermo Fisher | ||
Refrigerated Centrifuge | Fisher Sci | ||
SCD Sterile Tubing Welder | Terumo | ||
Sebra Tube Sealer | Sebra | ||
Varitherm | Barkey | The dry thaw device | |
XN-330 Hematology Analyzer | Sysmex |
Request permission to reuse the text or figures of this JoVE article
Request PermissionThis article has been published
Video Coming Soon
Copyright © 2025 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved