Sign In

A subscription to JoVE is required to view this content. Sign in or start your free trial.

In This Article

  • Summary
  • Abstract
  • Introduction
  • Protocol
  • Representative Results
  • Discussion
  • Acknowledgements
  • Materials
  • References
  • Reprints and Permissions

Summary

Quantifying the contact area and force applied by an atomic force microscope (AFM) probe tip to a sample surface enables nanoscale mechanical property determination. Best practices to implement AFM cantilever-based nanoindentation in air or fluid on soft and hard samples to measure elastic modulus or other nanomechanical properties are discussed.

Abstract

An atomic force microscope (AFM) fundamentally measures the interaction between a nanoscale AFM probe tip and the sample surface. If the force applied by the probe tip and its contact area with the sample can be quantified, it is possible to determine the nanoscale mechanical properties (e.g., elastic or Young's modulus) of the surface being probed. A detailed procedure for performing quantitative AFM cantilever-based nanoindentation experiments is provided here, with representative examples of how the technique can be applied to determine the elastic moduli of a wide variety of sample types, ranging from kPa to GPa. These include live mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and nuclei in physiological buffer, resin-embedded dehydrated loblolly pine cross-sections, and Bakken shales of varying composition.

Additionally, AFM cantilever-based nanoindentation is used to probe the rupture strength (i.e., breakthrough force) of phospholipid bilayers. Important practical considerations such as method choice and development, probe selection and calibration, region of interest identification, sample heterogeneity, feature size and aspect ratio, tip wear, surface roughness, and data analysis and measurement statistics are discussed to aid proper implementation of the technique. Finally, co-localization of AFM-derived nanomechanical maps with electron microscopy techniques that provide additional information regarding elemental composition is demonstrated.

Introduction

Understanding the mechanical properties of materials is one of the most fundamental and essential tasks in engineering. For the analysis of bulk material properties, there are numerous methods available to characterize the mechanical properties of material systems, including tensile tests1, compression tests2, and three- or four-point bending (flexural) tests3. While these microscale tests can provide invaluable information regarding bulk material properties, they are generally conducted to failure, and are hence destructive. Additionally, they lack the spatial resolution necessary to accurately i....

Protocol

NOTE: Due to the wide variety of commercially available AFMs and diversity of sample types and applications that exist for cantilever-based nanoindentation, the protocol that follows is intentionally designed to be relatively general in nature, focusing on the shared steps necessary for all cantilever-based nanoindentation experiments regardless of instrument or manufacturer. Because of this, the authors assume the reader possesses at least basic familiarity with operating the specific instrument chosen for performing ca.......

Representative Results

Force-displacement curves
Figure 7 shows representative, near-ideal F-D curves obtained from nanoindentation experiments performed in air on resin-embedded loblolly pine samples (Figure 7A) and in fluid (phosphate-buffered saline [PBS]) on mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) nuclei (Figure 7B). The use of any contact mechanics model relies on the accurate and reliable determination of the initial tip-sample contact po.......

Discussion

Sample preparation
For nanoindentation in air, common preparation methods include cryosectioning (e.g., tissue samples), grinding and/or polishing followed by ultramicrotoming (e.g., resin-embedded biological samples), ion milling or focused ion beam preparation (e.g., semiconductor, porous, or mixed hardness samples not amenable to polishing), mechanical or electrochemical polishing (e.g., metal alloys), or thin film deposition (e.g., atomic layer or chemical vapor deposition, molecular beam epita.......

Acknowledgements

All AFM experiments were performed in the Boise State University Surface Science Laboratory (SSL). SEM characterization was performed in the Boise State Center for Materials Characterization (BSCMC). Research reported in this publication regarding biofuel feedstocks was supported in part by the US Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Bioenergy Technologies Office as part of the Feedstock Conversion Interface Consortium (FCIC), and under DOE Idaho Operations Office Contract DE-AC07-051ID14517. Cell mechanics studies were supported by the National Institutes of Health (USA) under grants AG059923, AR075803, and P20GM109095, and by Natio....

Materials

NameCompanyCatalog NumberComments
Atomic force microscopeBrukerDimension IconUses Nanoscope control software, including PeakForce Quantitative Nanomechanical Mapping (PF-QNM), FastForce Volume (FFV), and Point-and-Shoot Ramping experimental workspaces
AtomicJAmerican Institute of Physicshttps://doi.org/10.1063/1.4881683Flexible, powerful, free open source Java-based force curve analysis software package. Supports numerous contact mechanic models, such as Hertz, Sneddon DMT, JKR, Maugis, and cone or pyramid (including blunt and truncated). Also includes a variety of initial contact point estimation methods to choose from. Supports batch processing of data and subsequent statistical analysis (e.g., averages, standard deviations, histograms, goodness of fit, etc.). Literature citation is: P. Hermanowicz, M. Sarna, K. Burda, and H. Gabryfigure-materials-1031, “AtomicJ: An open source software for analysis of force curves” Rev. Sci. Instrum. 85: 063703 (2014), https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4881683
Buffer solution (PBS)Fisher Chemical (NaCl), Sigma Aldrich (KCl), Fisher BioReagents (Na2HPO4 and KH2PO4)S271 (>99% purity NaCl), P9541 (>99% purity KCl), BP332(>99% purity Na2HPO4), BP362 (>99% purity KH2PO4)Phosphate buffered saline (PBS) was prepared in the laboratory as an aqueous solution consisting of 137 mM NaCl, 2.7 mM KCl, 10 mM Na2HPO4, and 1.8 mM KH2PO4 dissolved in ultrapure water. Reagents were measured out using an analytical balance, and glassware was cleaned with soap and water followed by autoclaving immediately prior to use.
Chloroform
Diamond tip AFM probeBrukerPDNISPPre-mounted factory-calibrated cube corner diamond (E = 1140 GPa) tip AFM probe (nominal R = 40 nm) with a stainless steel cantilever (nominal k = 225 N/m, f0 = 50 kHz). Spring constant is measured at the factory (k = 256 N/m for the probe, Serial #13435414, used here) and calibration data (including AFM images of indents showing probe geometry) is provided with the probe.
Diamond ultramicrotome bladeDiatomeUltra 35°2.1 mm width. Also used a standard glass blade for intial rough cut of sample surface before transitioning to diamond blade for final surface preparation
EpoxyGorilla Glue26853-31-6Epoxy resin and hardner were mixed in a 1:1 ratio, a small drop was placed on a stainless steel sample puck (Ted Pella), and V1 grade muscovite mica (Ted Pella) was attached to create an atomically flat surface for preparation of phospholipid membranes.
Ethanol
LR white resin, medium grade (catalyzed)Electron Microscopy Sciences14381500 mL bottle, Lot #150629
Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs)N/AN/AMSCs for nanomechanical studies were primary cells harvested from 8-10 week old male C57BL/6 mice as described in Goelzer, M. et al. "Lamin A/C Is Dispensable to Mechanical Repression of Adipogenesis" Int J Mol Sci 22: 6580 (2021) doi:10.3390/ijms22126580 and Peister, A. et al. "Adult stem cells from bone marrow (MSCs) isolated from different strains of inbred mice vary in surface epitopes, rates of proliferation, and differentiation potential" Blood 103: 1662-1668 (2004), doi:10.1182/blood-2003-09-3070.
Modulus standardsBrukerPFQNM-SMPKIT-12MUsed HOPG (E = 18 GPa) and PS (E = 2.7 GPa). Also contains 2x PDMS (Tack 0, E = 2.5 MPa; Tack 4, E = 3.5 MPa), PS-LDPE (E = 2.0/0.2 GPa), fused silica (E = 72.9 GPa), sapphire (E - 345 GPa), and tip characterization (titanium roughness) sample. All samples come pre-mounted on a 12 mm diameter steel disc (sample puck).
Muscovite micaTed Pella50-1212 mm diameter, V1 grade muscovite mica
Nanscope AnalysisBrukerVersion 2.0Free AFM image processing and analysis software package, but designed for, and proprietary/limited to Bruker AFMs; similar functionality is available from free, platform-independent AFM image processing and analysis software packages such as Gwyddion, WSxM, and others. Has built-in capabilities for force curve analysis, but AtomicJ is more flexible/full featured (e.g., more built-in contact mechanics models to choose from, statistical analysis of force curve fitting results, etc.) for force curve analysis and handles batch processing of force curves.
Phospholipids: POPC, Cholesterol (ovine)Avanti Polar LipidsPOPC: CAS # 26853-31-6, Cholesterol: CAS # 57-88-5POPC lipid dissolved in chloroform (25 mg/mL) was obtained from vendor and used without further purification. Cholesterol powder from the same vendor was dissolved in chloroform (20 mg/mL). 
Probe holder (fluid, lipid bilayers)BrukerMTFML-V2Specific to the particular AFM used; MTFML-V2 is a glass probe holder for scanning in fluid on a MultiMode AFM.
Probe holder (fluid, MSCs)BrukerFastScan Bio Z-scannerUsed with Dimension FastScan head (XY flexure scanners). Serial number MXYPOM5-1B154.
Probe holder (standard, ambient)BrukerDAFMCHSpecific to the particular AFM used; DAFMCH is the standard contact and tapping mode probe holder for the Dimension Icon AFM, suitable for nanoindentation (PF-QNM, FFV, and point-and-shoot ramping)
Sample PuckTed Pella16218Product number is for 15 mm diameter stainless steel sample puck. Also available in 6 mm, 10 mm, 12 mm, and 20 mm diameters at https://www.tedpella.com/AFM_html/AFM.aspx#anchor842459
Sapphire substrateBrukerPFQNM-SMPKIT-12MExtremely hard surface (E = 345 GPa) for measuring deflection sensitivity of probes (want all of the deflection to come from the probe, not the substrate). Part of the PF-QNM/modulus standards kit.
Scanning electron microscopeHitachiS-3400N-IILocated at Boise State. Used to perform co-localized SEM/EDS on all samples except additively manufactured (AM) Ti-6Al-4V.
Silicon AFM probes (standard)NuNanoScout 350Standard tapping mode silicon probe with reflective aluminum backside coating; k = 42 N/m (nominal), f0 = 350 kHz. Nominal R = 5 nm. Also available uncoated or with reflective gold backside coating. Probes with similar specifications are available from other manufacturers (e.g., Bruker TESPA-V2).
Silicon AFM probes (stiff)BrukerRTESPA-525, RTESPA-525-30 Rotated tip etched silicon probes with reflective aluminum backside coating; k = 200 N/m (nominal), f0 = 525 kHz. Nominal R = 8 nm for RTESPA-525, R = 30 nm for RTESPA-525-30. Spring constant of each RTESPA-525-30 is measured individually at the factory via laser Doppler vibrometry and supplied with the probe.
Silicon carbide grit paper (abrasive discs)Allied50-10005120 grit
Silicon nitride AFM probes (soft, large radius hemispherical tip)BrukerMLCT-SPH-5UM, MLCT-SPH-5UM-DCAlso MLCT-SPH-1UM-DC. New product line of factory-calibrated (probe radius and spring constants of all cantilevers) large radius (R = 1 or 5 mm) hemispherical tip (at the end of a 23 mm long cylindrical shaft) probes. DC = drift compensation coating. 6 cantilevers/probe (A-F). Nominal spring constants: A, k = 0.07 N/m; B, k = 0.02 N/m; C, k = 0.01 N/m; D, k = 0.03 N/m; E, k = 0.1 N/m; F, k = 0.6 N/m.
Silicon nitride AFM probes (soft, medium sharp tip)BrukerDNP4 cantilevers/probe (A-d). Nominal spring constants: A, k = 0.35 N/m; B, k = 0.12 N/m; C, k = 0.24 N/m; D, k = 0.06 N/m. Nominal radii of curvature, R = 10 nm.
Silicon nitride AFM probes (soft, sharp tip)BrukerScanAsyst-AirNominal values: resonance frequency, f0 = 70 kHz; spring constant, k = 0.4 N/m; radius of curvature, R = 2 nm. Designed for force curve based AFM imaging.
SuperglueHenkelLoctite 495Cyanoacrylate based instant adhesive. Lots of roughly equivalent products are readily available.
Syringe pumpNew Era Pump SystemsNE1000USOne channel syringe pump system with infusion and withdrawal capacity
Tip characterization standardBrukerPFQNM-SMPKIT-12MTitanium (Ti) roughness standard. Part of the PF-QNM/modulus standards kit.
Ultrahigh purity nitrogen (UHP N2), 99.999%NorcoSPG TUHPNI - TT size compressed gas cylinder of ultrahigh purity (99.999%) nitrogen for drying samples
UltramicrotomeLeicaEM UC6Equipped with a glass blade (standard, for intial sample preparation) and a diamond blade (for final preparation)
Ultrapure waterThermo FisherBarnstead Nanopure Model 7146Model has been discontinued, but equivalent products are available. Produces ≥18.2 MΩ*cm ultrapure water with 1-5 ppb TOC (total organic content), per inline UV monitoring. Includes 0.2 µm particulate filter, ion exchange columns, and UV oxidation chamber.
Variable Speed GrinderBuehlerEcoMet 3000Used with silicon carbide grit papers during hand polishing.
Vibration isolation table (active)HerzanTS-140Used with Bruker MultiMode AFM. Sits on a TMC 65-531 vibration isolation table. Bruker Dimension Icon AFM utilizes strictly passive vibration isolation (comes from manufacturer with custom acoustic hood, air table, and granite slab).
Vibration isolation table (passive)TMC65-53135" x 30" vibration isolation table with optional air damping (disabled). Used with Bruker MultiMode AFM. Herzan TS-140 "Table Stable" active vibration control table is located on top.

References

  1. Hart, E. W. Theory of the tensile test. Acta Metallurgica. 15 (2), 351-355 (1967).
  2. Fell, J. T., Newton, J. M. Determination of tablet strength by the diametral-compression test. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences. 59....

Explore More Articles

Atomic Force MicroscopyAFMCantilever based NanoindentationNanoscaleMechanical PropertiesModulusAirFluidTopographical ImagingQuantitative MeasurementsCalibrationProbeForceDisplacementDeflection Sensitivity

This article has been published

Video Coming Soon

JoVE Logo

Privacy

Terms of Use

Policies

Research

Education

ABOUT JoVE

Copyright © 2024 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved